Is factoring the same as confirming?

No. Both allow a supplier to be paid an invoice before it falls due, but they start from different sides. In factoring, it is the supplier who assigns its invoices to a financial institution, which advances the money and takes care of collecting from the customer. In reverse factoring (“confirming”), it is the customer who instructs its bank to pay its suppliers, to whom the bank offers to advance payment. Whether the supplier has to return the money if the customer does not pay depends on whether the advance was agreed with recourse or without recourse.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Factoring

Factoring is arranged by the business that sells. It assigns to a financial institution, called the factor, the claims it has against its customers, that is, its invoices awaiting payment. The factor manages and collects them when they fall due and, normally, advances their amount to the supplier, deducting interest and fees. It has no law of its own. It relies on the rules on assignment of debts in the Commercial Code (“Código de Comercio”) and the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”).

The customer's consent is not needed to assign the invoices. It is enough to notify the customer of the assignment. Until the customer knows of it, they are discharged if they pay the supplier. From the moment they know, they pay validly only if they pay the factor.

There are two types:

  • With recourse. If the customer does not pay, the factor can claim from the supplier what it advanced. The risk of non-payment remains with the supplier.
  • Without recourse. The factor bears the risk that the customer proves insolvent.

Confirming

Confirming is arranged by the business that buys. It instructs its bank to manage payments to its suppliers. The bank tells each supplier which invoices its customer has approved and the date on which they will be paid. It also offers to pay them earlier, at a discount. The supplier is free to accept the advance or to wait until the due date. If it accepts, it assigns its invoice to the bank.

Nor does it have a law of its own. Confirming is a way of managing payment and does not change the maximum period that the law sets for paying suppliers. Nor does the bank's notification that an invoice is approved always mean that it guarantees payment on the due date, because that depends on what it has agreed with its customer.

If the customer does not pay

What happens depends on what has been signed:

  • In factoring with recourse, the supplier has to return to the factor what has been advanced and claim the invoice itself from its customer.
  • In factoring without recourse, the supplier keeps what it has received if the non-payment is due to the customer's insolvency.
  • In confirming, the advance is normally made without recourse, so a supplier that has already been paid does not have to return anything. It is worth checking this in the bank's terms before accepting it.

In every case, the supplier warrants that the invoice exists and is genuine. If the customer does not pay because it disputes the goods or the service, or because the invoice did not correspond to a real transaction, the institution may claim from the supplier even if the advance was without recourse. For that reason, it is worth reading in the contract exactly which non-payments it covers and what obligations the supplier has, such as reporting any problem with the customer. It is also worth checking that the contract with the customer does not prohibit assigning invoices.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.