What majority is needed to approve the annual accounts at the annual general meeting?
The ordinary majority, which is the lowest the law provides for, because approving the accounts does not require any enhanced majority. In a limited company, a majority of the votes cast is needed, provided that the votes in favour represent at least one third of all the votes in the company. In a public limited company, a simple majority of the votes of the shareholders present or represented is enough, that is, more votes in favour than against. The articles of association can require a higher majority, so it is worth reading them before the meeting.
Alburquerque Abogados
In a limited company
In a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) each quota (“participación”) carries one vote, unless the articles of association say otherwise. To approve the accounts, two conditions must be met at the same time:
- The majority of the votes validly cast must be in favour. Blank votes are not counted, so in practice there must be more votes in favour than against.
- The votes in favour must represent at least one third of the votes of all the quotas into which the capital is divided, whether or not their holders attended the meeting.
For example, in a company with 3.000 quotas, if shareholders holding 2.000 attend and 1.200 vote in favour and 800 against, the accounts are approved. If only shareholders holding 1.500 attend and 900 vote in favour and 600 against, they are not approved, because 900 votes do not reach the one third of the total, which is 1.000.
The law does not require a minimum attendance to hold the meeting in a limited company. Nor does it prevent a shareholder who is also a director from voting, even if that person drew up the accounts.
In a public limited company
In a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”), the meeting is only quorate on the first call if shareholders holding at least 25 % of the voting capital attend, present or represented. On the second call any attendance is enough, unless the articles of association set a minimum. Once the meeting is quorate, the accounts are approved by a simple majority, that is, when the resolution receives more votes in favour than against from the capital present or represented.
In both types of company, the meeting decides by that same majority what is to be done with the profit for the year.
The articles of association and a tie
The articles of association can raise these majorities. In a limited company they can require a higher percentage of votes for all resolutions or for some of them, short of unanimity. They can also require the favourable vote of a given number of shareholders. In a public limited company they can also raise the majority.
An enhanced majority, which is one requiring more votes than the ordinary majority, protects the minority shareholder but can block the company. If the articles of association require 60 % of the votes and a shareholder with 45 % votes against, the accounts are not approved.
The same happens with a tie. In a company with two shareholders at 50 % each, if one votes in favour and the other against, there is no majority and the accounts remain unapproved. Unapproved accounts cannot be filed with the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). If the situation recurs, it can become a legal ground for dissolution, the paralysis of the company's governing bodies. How to get out of that deadlock is a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.