Can you take money out of a limited company without justification?
No, because the company's money belongs to the company and not to its shareholders, even if there is only one. It can only pass to the shareholder by a lawful route, such as a dividend, the director's remuneration, a loan approved by the general meeting or payment for real work or a real service. Every payment out has to be documented and recorded in the accounts. Whatever is taken out by none of those routes has to be repaid and can make the director liable. There are also tax consequences, which need to be studied separately.
Alburquerque Abogados
Why you cannot
A limited company (“sociedad limitada”) has its own legal personality and assets separate from those of its shareholders. That separation is what allows shareholders not to answer with their own property for the company's debts. In return, the money in the company's account is not at the shareholder's disposal, even if they hold all the quotas (“participaciones”) or are also the director.
The law also requires the company to keep orderly accounts that allow all its transactions to be followed and to keep the supporting documents for six years. A payment out cannot go unrecorded. If it does not fall under any of the lawful routes, it appears in the accounts as a debt owed by the shareholder to the company. Paying personal expenses with the company's card or account amounts to taking the money out.
The lawful routes for being paid by the company
A shareholder can receive money from the company by these routes, each with its own requirements:
- A dividend, which the general meeting resolves when approving the accounts, respecting the legal reserve and the other limits in the law.
- The remuneration of the post of director, if the articles of association provide that it is paid and the general meeting has approved its maximum annual amount.
- Payment for real work or a real service, with its contract or invoice. In a limited company, contracts for services or works with a director need a resolution of the general meeting.
- A loan from the company to the shareholder, which in a limited company requires a resolution of the general meeting in each case.
- The return of contributions in a capital reduction and the distribution of what is left when the company is liquidated.
- Reimbursement of expenses that the shareholder has paid on the company's behalf, with the supporting documents.
What happens if money is taken out without justification
The shareholder has to repay what was taken and the company can claim it back. If it was in reality a distribution of profits made without a resolution of the general meeting or without respecting the legal limits, a shareholder who knew of the irregularity, or could not have been unaware of it, must repay it with statutory interest.
The director is also liable. If the director is the one who takes the money, they breach their duty of loyalty, which forbids using the company's assets for private purposes. They have to compensate the harm and return whatever they have obtained. If they allow a shareholder to take it out, they may have to answer for the harm caused. The claim can be brought by the company, if the general meeting so resolves, or by shareholders holding at least 5 % of the capital in the cases laid down by law. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
If the company leaves debts unpaid, the consequences are greater. The usual mixing of the company's money with the shareholder's can lead the courts to disregard the separation between the two sets of assets and make the shareholder answer for those debts. If the company is insolvent, it has to file for insolvency proceedings, the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”, or, if it is a micro-enterprise, for the special procedure provided for micro-enterprises, within the legal time limit. In those proceedings, payments out of the previous two years that harmed the creditors can be set aside. In the most serious cases, using the company's money to its detriment can be a criminal offence, which is a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.