Is it possible to distribute dividends to only one shareholder?
As a general rule, no. When the general meeting resolves on a dividend, all the shareholders receive it in proportion to their holding in the capital. In a limited company, the articles of association may lay down a different rule, for example quotas (“participaciones”) carrying a larger or preferential dividend, but they cannot leave a shareholder with no share at all in the profits. Without such a rule in the articles, the majority cannot resolve that only one shareholder is to be paid. What each shareholder can do is waive their own dividend.
Alburquerque Abogados
The rule and what the articles of association can change
Every shareholder has the right to share in the company's profits. In a limited company (“sociedad limitada”), the law says that the dividend is distributed in proportion to each shareholder's holding in the capital, unless the articles of association provide otherwise. In a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”), ordinary shares are paid in proportion to the capital paid up, although shares with a preferential dividend may also be created.
The articles of association may therefore depart from proportionality. This is usually done with preferential quotas (“participaciones”), which give the right to a larger dividend or to be paid ahead of the others. With a preferential dividend it can happen that in a given year only its holder is paid, if the profit does not stretch further. That freedom has limits:
- A shareholder cannot be excluded from any share in the profits. An agreement to that effect is void.
- Quotas cannot be created with a right to receive interest, that is, a guaranteed sum whether or not there are profits.
- If the privilege is introduced by amending the articles of association of a limited company and affects the individual rights of a shareholder, the consent of those affected is required.
If the general meeting resolves to pay only one
A majority resolution that distributes the dividend to a single shareholder, or to some shareholders and not others, when the articles of association do not allow it, is contrary to the law. Shareholders who are harmed and who hold at least 1 % of the capital may challenge it and ask to be paid their share. A shareholder who does not reach that percentage, which the articles of association may lower, is entitled to compensation for the harm the resolution causes. The time limit for a challenge is one year, with exceptions. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
It is different where a shareholder decides not to collect. Once the dividend has been resolved, each shareholder is a creditor of the company for their share and may waive it. It is their own decision, which the majority cannot impose on them.
If all the shareholders want a different distribution for a particular year, at the very least each shareholder who will receive less than their entitlement must expressly accept it. The safest course is to put the rule into the articles of association first. Both a waiver and an unequal distribution have tax consequences that need to be studied separately.
Other ways of rewarding a shareholder
Often, what is wanted is to pay more to the shareholder who works in the business or who contributes something the others do not. A dividend is no use for that, because it rewards capital. The law offers other instruments, such as remuneration for the office of director, if the articles of association provide for it, or paid ancillary obligations (“prestaciones accesorias”), which are obligations other than the capital contribution that the articles of association impose on a shareholder in return for compensation. Each has its own requirements, which are a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.