What are the disadvantages of a franchise agreement?

For the franchisee, the main ones are three. The franchisee signs a contract drafted by the franchisor, with little room to negotiate it and without the protection that the law gives consumers against unfair terms. The franchisee alone bears the risk of the business, because it invests, takes the premises and pays the fees even if sales fall short of forecasts. And the franchisee loses freedom, because it has to follow the network's guidelines, buy from whoever it is told to and accept limits on selling the business or on competing when the contract ends. Knowing these risks before signing makes it possible to negotiate some of them and to judge whether the deal is worthwhile.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

A contract drafted by the other side

The franchisor offers the same contract to its whole network and accepts few changes. The franchisee signs as a businessperson, so the rules that annul unfair terms in contracts with consumers do not apply. A clause generally fails only if it was not genuinely brought to the franchisee's attention before signing, if it is illegible or incomprehensible or if it goes against a mandatory rule. That is why what is signed is, in practice, what will apply.

Before signing, the law requires the franchisor to provide in writing, at least twenty working days in advance, truthful information about its business, the network and the contract. Any sales forecasts it includes must be well founded, but they are not a promise of results.

The risk lies with the franchisee

The franchisee is neither a partner of the franchisor nor a branch of it. The franchisee is a businessperson who runs the business in its own name, so the losses are its own. These are the most common consequences:

  • The initial investment, the rent for the premises and the financing are at the franchisee's expense. If the business is run through a company and a personal guarantee is requested, the franchisee also answers with its own assets.
  • The fees and the contributions to advertising are paid as agreed, normally on sales and not on profit.
  • The brand is not the franchisee's. If the network loses prestige or the franchisor runs into difficulties, the franchisee's business suffers without being able to prevent it.
  • The term may be short for recovering the investment. The law gives no right to renewal or to goodwill compensation when the contract ends, so the contract should deal with it.

The ties during the contract and afterwards

While the contract lasts, the franchisee has to follow the manuals and accept the franchisor's supervision. It is usual for the franchisee to have to buy from the franchisor or from approved suppliers and not to be able to engage in a competing business. If the contract does not reserve an exclusive territory, the franchisor may in principle open another outlet nearby or sell online to the same customers. Retail prices, on the other hand, cannot generally be imposed on the franchisee, although the franchisor may recommend them or set a maximum.

These clauses deserve particular care in review:

  • Transfer. The franchisee normally cannot sell or assign the business without the franchisor's permission, while the franchisor usually also reserves a right of first refusal.
  • Termination, which is the ending of the contract for breach. Some contracts allow the franchisor to end it for minor breaches and add penalties.
  • The end. The franchisee has to stop using the brand and the network's signs, which means changing the look of the premises.
  • The post-contract non-compete. Competition law only generally protects it if it lasts one year at most, is limited to the premises from which the franchisee worked and is necessary to protect the know-how passed on.
  • Disputes. The contract may refer them to arbitration, the cost of which should be understood. A clause sending disputes to the courts of another city in Spain, on the other hand, is generally not valid in a contract imposed without negotiation.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.