What happens if a trade mark is similar to another?
It depends on whether the similarity could lead the public to confuse them. Two similar trade marks can coexist if they distinguish different goods or services, but where the signs and the goods or services are identical or similar and the public may confuse them, the earlier trade mark prevails. Its owner can oppose registration of the new one, apply to have it declared invalid if it is already registered and demand that it stop being used. The trade mark office does not do this on the owner's behalf, so the owner has to monitor the register and act within the time limit. Trade marks with a reputation, which are those known to a significant part of the public they are aimed at, are also protected against similar signs for different goods or services.
Alburquerque Abogados
When there is a likelihood of confusion
There is a likelihood of confusion when the public may believe that the goods or services of the two trade marks come from the same business or from related businesses. This includes the risk that they associate one trade mark with the other. It is assessed as a whole, taking into account these factors:
- The similarity of the signs, in how they look, how they sound and what they mean.
- The identity or similarity of the goods or services.
- The distinctive character of the earlier trade mark, which is greater the more original or the better known it is.
- The public the trade marks are aimed at and the attention it pays when choosing.
Some factors make up for others. A strong similarity between the signs can make up for a lesser similarity between the goods. The same is true the other way round. Moreover, consumers do not usually have both trade marks in front of them and rely on the imperfect memory they keep of them.
Where there is no likelihood of confusion, two similar trade marks can coexist, as happens when they distinguish goods or services that are unrelated. The exception is trade marks with a reputation, whose owner can also act against signs for different goods if the other party, without due cause, takes unfair advantage of their prestige or harms it.
If the similar trade mark is being applied for
The “Oficina Española de Patentes y Marcas” (OEPM), the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office, does not refuse an application on its own initiative because it resembles an earlier trade mark. It only notifies, for information, the owners of the earlier trade marks that it identifies. It is the owner of the earlier trade mark who has to file an opposition, within two months of the application being published in the “Boletín Oficial de la Propiedad Industrial”, the official industrial property gazette. For EU trade marks, the period is three months from publication. Earlier rights include Spanish trade marks, EU trade marks and international trade marks with effect in Spain, as well as trade names.
The person applying for the trade mark can defend their position. They can argue that there is no likelihood of confusion, limit their list of goods or services or reach an agreement with the opponent. If the earlier trade mark has been registered for at least five years, they can require its owner to prove that it has genuinely been used. If the owner cannot, the opposition is dismissed.
If it is already registered or in use
If the similar trade mark is already registered, the owner of the earlier one can apply to have it declared invalid. If it is a Spanish trade mark, since 14 January 2023 the application is made to the OEPM. If it is an EU trade mark, it is made to the European Union Intellectual Property Office, the EUIPO. The courts decide on invalidity only when the defendant raises it in trade mark infringement proceedings. Here too, proof of use of the earlier trade mark can be demanded.
That application has a limit. Anyone who knowingly tolerates the use of a later registered trade mark for five years in a row can no longer apply to have it declared invalid, unless it was applied for in bad faith.
If the similar sign is used in the market, the owner of the earlier trade mark can also go to court to have the use stopped and to be compensated, which is a separate matter. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.
For all these reasons, it is advisable to search for earlier trade marks before choosing your own. Once it is registered, you need to monitor new applications in order to oppose them in time.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.