Which acts are considered unfair competition?

Under the general rule of the “Ley de Competencia Desleal”, Spain's Unfair Competition Act, any conduct in the market that is objectively contrary to good faith is unfair. The Act also describes specific acts, such as misleading people about a product, causing confusion with another business or its products, discrediting a competitor, taking advantage of its reputation, breaching its trade secrets or inducing its employees, suppliers or customers to breach their contracts. It is not necessary for the person who does it and the person who suffers it to be competitors. On the other hand, competing with better prices, winning over other businesses' customers or copying what is not protected by an exclusive right is not, in itself, unfair.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

When conduct is unfair

The Act applies to businesses, to professionals and to any other person or body taking part in the market. For conduct to amount to unfair competition it must take place in the market and for competitive purposes, that is, it must serve to promote the sale of one's own products or services or those of a third party.

The general rule of good faith applies to conduct that does not fit any of the acts the Act describes. Unfairness is assessed objectively, without any need to prove that there was an intention to harm anyone.

The acts the Act describes

In addition to the general rule, the Act describes the following unfair acts:

  • Deception, which means giving false information, or true information presented in a way that misleads, about the product, the price or the business itself. Concealing the information needed to make a decision is also deception.
  • Confusion with another business's activity, products or premises. The risk that consumers will associate them is enough.
  • Disparagement, which means spreading statements that may damage another's standing in the market, unless they are accurate, true and relevant.
  • Public comparison with a competitor, including comparative advertising, where it does not meet the legal requirements, for example because it does not refer to objective and verifiable features.
  • Copying another's products or initiatives where this may lead consumers to associate them or amounts to unfairly taking advantage of that other's reputation or effort.
  • Exploiting another's reputation, for example by advertising a product as a “type” or “model” of someone else's brand.
  • Breach of trade secrets, which has its own Act.
  • Inducing a competitor's employees, suppliers or customers to breach the basic obligations of their contracts.
  • Breach of rules, where a significant competitive advantage gained by infringing the law is exploited in the market. The Act includes here repeated breaches of the rules against late payment.
  • Discriminating against consumers in prices or terms of sale without justified cause and exploiting the economic dependence of customers or suppliers who have no equivalent alternative.
  • Selling below cost, where this misleads people about the establishment's price level, discredits another product or establishment or forms part of a strategy to eliminate a competitor.
  • Aggressive practices, which impair the recipient's freedom of choice through harassment, coercion or undue influence.
  • Unlawful advertising.

The Act also devotes a chapter to unfair practices towards consumers, such as pyramid selling or hidden advertising.

What is not unfair competition

Competing is not unfair, even if it harms others. Winning customers with better prices or a better service is lawful. Copying other people's products and initiatives is free, unless they are protected by an exclusive right, such as a patent, a design or a trade mark, or one of the cases above applies.

A former employee or collaborator going on to compete is not unfair in itself either. It becomes unfair if they use trade secrets, mislead customers or induce others to breach their contracts. Non-competition agreements, such as those of employees, are a separate matter.

How to bring a claim against an unfair act is a separate matter, but it is worth knowing that the time limits for doing so are short.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.