What are trade secrets?
A trade secret is any information or knowledge, whether technological, scientific, industrial, commercial, organisational or financial, that meets three conditions. It must be secret, have commercial value precisely because it is secret and have been protected by its holder with reasonable measures to keep it secret. It is not entered in any register and its protection lasts for as long as the information remains secret. The “Ley de Secretos Empresariales”, Spain's Trade Secrets Act, allows its holder to go to the civil courts against anyone who obtains, uses or discloses it unlawfully.
Alburquerque Abogados
The three conditions
For information to be a trade secret, the Act requires it to meet all of the following conditions at the same time:
- That it is secret, that is, not generally known to the people who habitually work with that type of information nor easily accessible to them.
- That it has commercial value, real or potential, precisely because it is secret.
- That its holder has taken reasonable measures to keep it secret.
A formula, a manufacturing process, the code of a program, a business plan or data on customers, suppliers, costs and prices can all qualify, if they meet the conditions. The third condition is the one most often neglected. If the business has done nothing to protect the information, it will not be able to rely on the Act. What counts includes, for example, confidentiality agreements with those who have access to it, passwords, restricting access to those who really need it and marking documents as confidential.
The secret forms part of the business's assets. It can be transferred and another person can be authorised to use it under a licence.
What is permitted and what is not
The Act does not prevent someone else from arriving at the same information by lawful means. Independent discovery or creation and the study or dismantling of a product that is available to the public or lawfully possessed are lawful, as long as no valid obligation prevents it. Protection of a secret also cannot be used to restrict employees' mobility or to stop them using the experience and skills they have honestly acquired during their professional career.
A secret is breached, on the other hand, in the following cases:
- Obtaining it without the holder's consent through unauthorised access to, copying of or appropriation of documents, files or other media, or by any other conduct contrary to fair commercial practices.
- Using or disclosing it without consent, by someone who obtained it unlawfully or who breaches a confidentiality agreement or another obligation limiting its use.
- Obtaining, using or disclosing it, by someone who knew, or should have known, that it came from a person who was using or disclosing it unlawfully.
- Manufacturing, offering or marketing infringing goods, which are goods that benefit significantly from a secret that was unlawfully obtained, used or disclosed, where the person doing so knew or should have known that origin.
How to defend it
The holder can ask the court to declare the breach, to order it to stop or prohibit it, to prohibit the manufacture or marketing of the infringing goods and order their withdrawal, to have the media containing the secret handed over and to be compensated for damages if the infringer acted intentionally or negligently. The time limit for claiming is three years from when the holder found out who committed the breach.
The case is heard by the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”) for the defendant's domicile or, if the claimant prefers, the one for the province where the infringement was committed or had its effects. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim. During the proceedings, the judge may restrict access to the documents and hearings so that the secret is not lost in the trial itself.
Breach of a trade secret is also an act of unfair competition and some of that conduct is also a crime, which is a separate matter. Employees' non-competition agreements are also a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.