How valid is a confidentiality agreement?

It is valid and binding like any other contract, because the law allows the parties to agree whatever they wish as long as it is not contrary to law, morality or public policy. It needs no notary or particular form, although without a signed document it is very hard to prove what information was handed over and what the recipient undertook. Its real usefulness depends on its defining properly the protected information, the permitted use, the duration and the consequences of breaching it. It also has limits, because it does not protect what is already public nor can it prevent a legal duty to disclose from being met.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Why it is valid and what it is for

The confidentiality agreement, also known by its English initials, NDA, rests on the freedom of contract recognised by the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”), which also applies in Catalonia in this respect. What is signed has the force of law between the parties. It may bind only one party, the one receiving the information, or both, if both are going to exchange it, as happens when negotiating a collaboration or the sale of a business.

It has another use as well. The “Ley de Secretos Empresariales”, the Spanish Trade Secrets Act, protects only information that its owner has tried to keep secret by reasonable measures. Having a confidentiality agreement signed before showing the information is one of the most common such measures. That same law treats it as unlawful to use or disclose a secret in breach of a confidentiality agreement, so whoever signs one is exposed to a claim for breach of contract and to the remedies under that law.

What it must say

For it to be effective, the agreement should specify the following:

  • What information is confidential, with a definition that makes it possible to identify it. Also how information communicated orally is treated.
  • What the recipient may use it for and which of its employees or advisers may see it, with a commitment that they too will respect it.
  • What is excluded, such as information that was already public, information the recipient already knew or develops independently or information it must hand over by order of a court or an authority.
  • How long the obligation lasts and what is done when it ends, normally returning or destroying the documents.
  • What happens in the event of breach. Because the harm caused by a leak is hard to prove, it is common to agree a penalty clause (“cláusula penal”), that is, a sum fixed in advance that is payable without the need to prove loss.
  • The governing law and the courts, if the other party is foreign.

Duration and limits

The law sets neither a minimum nor a maximum duration. The usual approach is to agree a number of years from signature or from the end of the relationship. For trade secrets it may be agreed that the obligation lasts for as long as the information remains secret. If the agreement says nothing, it is easy for a dispute to arise over how long it binds, so it is advisable to fix this.

The agreement cannot do everything either. It does not make confidential what is already in the public domain. Nor can it be used to prevent someone from using experience and skills honestly acquired in the course of their career, which the law leaves outside the protection of secrecy. And it does not cover silence about illegal activity, because the law does not protect the owner of the secret against someone who discloses it in order to uncover such activity in the public interest. Confidentiality agreed with employees also has its own employment rules, which are a separate matter.

If the other party breaches the agreement, it may be required to stop using the information and to compensate the harm, which has to be proved unless a penalty has been agreed. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.