What happens if you stop paying an operating lease (“renting”)?
From the first unpaid instalment, the leasing company can claim the arrears together with late-payment interest. If the non-payment continues, it can terminate the contract, demand the return of the asset and collect, in addition to the instalments already due, the penalty the contract provides for, which is usually a percentage of the instalments that remained until the end. If the asset is not returned, it can ask the court to order its handover. The penalty is, in principle, payable as agreed, although it can be challenged in some cases, especially if the person who signed the contract is a consumer.
Alburquerque Abogados
From the first unpaid instalment
An operating lease (“renting”) is a form of hire and its instalment must be paid on the agreed date. Late payment has the following consequences from the start:
- Late-payment interest is due at the rate the contract sets or, if it sets none, at the rate provided by law.
- The company can claim the unpaid instalments and, if there are guarantors, claim them from the guarantors too.
- It can report the debt to a defaulters' register. If the debtor is an individual, it may only do so if, among other requirements, it warned them of that possibility in the contract or when demanding payment.
While the contract remains in force, ceasing to use the asset does not stop the instalments from falling due.
Termination and return of the asset
The contract will normally allow the company to terminate it, that is, to bring it to an end, when one or more instalments go unpaid. Instead of terminating, it can keep the contract alive and claim the instalments as they fall due or, if the contract so provides, all those outstanding at once.
Once the contract has been terminated, you must return the asset. If you do not, the company can go to court, although the law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim. Where the contract is registered in the “Registro de Bienes Muebles”, Spain's register of movable property, using the official form, the company has a faster route, which follows these steps:
- A notary serves a formal demand on you to pay what is claimed or hand over the asset within three working days.
- If you do neither, the company can ask the court to order the immediate handover of the asset. An appeal against that decision does not stop it.
If the contract was signed before a notary, in a public deed or a notarial policy (“póliza”), the company can also directly apply for the attachment of your assets for the amounts owed, without a prior trial.
The penalty and its limits
In addition to the instalments already due, the contract usually sets a penalty for ending early, often calculated as a percentage of the instalments that remained. It is a penalty clause, that is, compensation fixed in advance, which the company can collect without proving any loss. What can be challenged depends on who the customer is:
- If it is a company or a self-employed person (“autónomo”) who entered into the contract for their business, the penalty is, in principle, payable as agreed. The judge will not reduce it merely because it turns out to be high. The judge can do so only in limited cases, for example if it was meant for a total breach and the contract has been partly performed.
- If it is a consumer, a clause imposing disproportionately high compensation is unfair and is treated as never written. The company keeps its right to collect the instalments already due and to recover the asset.
If you expect that you will not be able to keep paying, do not wait until you default. Propose a way out to the company in writing, such as early return with an agreed settlement figure, a payment schedule or the assignment of the contract to another company. If you reach an agreement, ask for the agreement to record in writing what is being paid and that nothing further is owed as a result.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.