What is the difference between an agency agreement and a commission agency?

The main difference is stability. A commission agency is a one-off engagement, for a specific transaction or several, which the commission agent may carry out in their own name or in the name of the person who engages them. An agency agreement is an ongoing relationship, in which the agent promotes transactions for a business on a stable basis and, if they conclude them, does so in the business's name. The commission agency is governed by the Commercial Code (“Código de Comercio”) and above all by what has been agreed, whereas agency has its own law with rights that the contract cannot cut back, such as notice or goodwill compensation. What decides the matter is not the name given to the contract but what the parties actually do.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

What each contract is

A commission agency (“comisión mercantil”) is a mandate, that is, an engagement to act on another's behalf, which concerns a commercial transaction and in which at least one of the parties is a businessperson. The person who gives the engagement is called the principal (“comitente”) and the person who carries it out, the commission agent (“comisionista”). An example is an engagement to sell a consignment of goods or to buy a machine.

The commission agent can contract in two ways. If they do so in the principal's name, they must say so and the contract with the third party is the principal's. If they do so in their own name, they do not have to say for whom they are acting and are bound directly to the third party, as if the business were theirs. In that case, in principle, the third party and the principal cannot claim against each other.

The agent, by contrast, undertakes on a stable basis to promote transactions for a business. The agent concludes them only if given that power and always in the name of the business, which is the party bound to the customer.

The differences that matter most

Besides stability, the two contracts differ in the following respects:

  • The governing rules. The commission agency is governed by the Commercial Code (“Código de Comercio”), with rules that for the most part give way to what has been agreed. The agency agreement is governed by the “Ley 12/1992”, Spain's commercial agency act, whose rules are mandatory, that is, they cannot be changed by the contract except where the law itself allows it.
  • Remuneration. The commission agent earns the commission agreed or, if none was agreed, the usual one in the place where they carry out the engagement. For the agent, the law also regulates when the right to commission arises, when it is paid and how the agent can check it.
  • Expenses. The principal must reimburse the commission agent for the expenses of the engagement and anything advanced, with statutory interest. The agent, unless otherwise agreed, bears the expenses of their own activity.
  • Termination. The principal can revoke the engagement at any time, although the principal remains bound by what the commission agent has handled up to then. To end an indefinite agency agreement, written notice of one month for each year it has lasted must be given, up to a maximum of six.
  • Compensation. When the agency agreement ends, the agent may be entitled to goodwill compensation (“indemnización por clientela”) for the customer base left to the business. The Commercial Code provides nothing similar for the commission agent.

Why it matters to tell them apart

The agency law applies to any relationship that has its features, whatever it is called. If someone whom the contract calls a commission agent promotes transactions for a company on a stable basis and as an independent professional, that person is an agent and has the rights the law gives, even if the contract says otherwise. Conversely, a one-off engagement does not become an agency by being called one.

It is therefore advisable to describe clearly in the contract what is being entrusted and for how long. If the intermediary actually works under the direction of the company, with no power to organise their own activity or time, the relationship may be one of employment, which is a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.