Who must sign the minutes of the general meeting of shareholders?
The minutes are signed by the secretary of the meeting, with the chair's “visto bueno” (approval), once they have been approved. The shareholders do not have to sign them, except at a universal meeting (“junta universal”), at which all those attending must sign after their names. If the meeting does not approve the minutes at the end of the meeting, they are approved within the following fifteen days by the chair and two shareholders acting as scrutineers (“interventores”), one for the majority and one for the minority. When a notary draws up the minutes of the meeting, the minutes are the notary's own and need neither those signatures nor approval.
Alburquerque Abogados
The chair and the secretary
All the resolutions of the meeting must be recorded in minutes. Once approved, the minutes are signed by the secretary of the meeting with the approval of whoever acted as chair. Unless the articles of association say otherwise, the chair and the secretary of the meeting are those of the board of directors. If there is no board, which is the most common situation in a small limited company, they are chosen by the shareholders present at the start of the meeting.
The minutes record, among other details, the date and place of the meeting, how it was called, the shareholders attending and the capital they represent, a summary of what was discussed, the resolutions and the result of the votes. In a limited company, the list of attendees forms part of the minutes.
Approval of the minutes
The signature comes after approval, which can be done in two ways:
- By the meeting itself, at the end of the meeting. This is the simplest course, because the minutes are closed that same day.
- By the chair of the meeting and two shareholders acting as scrutineers, one representing the majority and the other the minority, within the following fifteen days. In that case it is usual for the scrutineers to sign as well.
The minutes record when and how they were approved. The resolutions can be implemented from the date of that approval.
The other shareholders do not sign the minutes and their signature is not needed for the minutes to be valid. A shareholder who voted against does not prevent approval by refusing to sign. If they want their opposition to a resolution to be on record, what they should ask is for it to be recorded in the minutes.
Special cases
The rule changes in three cases:
- The universal meeting, which is the one held without notice with all the shareholders present or represented. The minutes must include the names of those attending, each followed by their signature.
- Notarial minutes (“acta notarial”). If a notary attends the meeting and draws up the minutes, those are the minutes of the meeting. They are not submitted for approval and do not have to be signed by the chair and the secretary.
- The single-member company. There is no meeting, only decisions of the sole shareholder, which are recorded in minutes signed by that shareholder or their representative.
The minutes should not be confused with the certificate. The minutes are kept in the company's minute book. What is taken to the notary or the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) is a certificate, a document that reproduces the resolutions and is signed by the person with power to certify. It may be the sole director, any of the directors acting individually (“solidarios”), the directors acting jointly (“mancomunados”) who together represent the company or, if there is a board, its secretary with the chair's approval.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.