When can shareholders request a notary at the general meeting?

Shareholders representing at least 5 % of the capital in a limited company, or 1 % in a public limited company, can require it, provided they ask the directors five days before the date set for the meeting. The directors are then obliged to engage a notary to attend and take the minutes. If they do not, the resolutions of that meeting are not effective, because the law then requires them to be recorded in a notarial record (“acta notarial”). The notary's record needs no approval, it is the record of the meeting and its fees are paid by the company.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Who can ask and how far in advance

The directors can bring a notary to any meeting on their own initiative. What the law adds is a minority right, which obliges them to do so when two conditions are met:

  • The percentage. Those asking must represent, alone or by adding their quotas (“participaciones”) together, at least 5 % of the capital of the limited company. In a public limited company 1 % is enough.
  • The notice. The request has to be made at least five days before the day set for the meeting. It is advisable to send it as soon as the notice of the meeting is received.

The law does not prescribe a form for the request, but it is in the shareholders' interest to use a means that proves the content and the date on which the directors receive it, such as a “burofax” (a certified letter with proof of content). If the request is made by a formal notarial demand to the directors, it can also be noted in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”). From that moment, the resolutions of that meeting are not registered unless they are recorded in a notarial record (“acta notarial”).

The request applies to the meeting that has been called and has to be repeated for later ones. A shareholder who does not reach the percentage can still ask, but the directors are not obliged to comply.

What the notary does and what weight the notary's record carries

The notary is engaged by the directors, not by the shareholder who asks. Before accepting, the notary checks that the meeting has been called in accordance with the law and the articles of association. At the meeting the notary identifies the chairman and the secretary and records the chairman's statement that the meeting is validly constituted, the proposals put to the vote and the resolutions adopted. The notary also records objections to resolutions and other contributions when asked. The notary does not run the meeting or assess whether what happens at it is lawful.

A notarial record differs from an ordinary set of minutes in three ways:

  • It is not put to approval and does not need the signature of the chairman and the secretary of the meeting.
  • It counts as the minutes of the meeting and is copied into the company's minute book.
  • The resolutions it records can be carried out from the date on which the notary closes it.

The notary's fees are borne by the company, even though the minority requested the notary's presence.

What it is for and what happens if it is not complied with

A notarial record matters most when there is a conflict between the shareholders. It establishes, with the authority of a notary, who chaired, what was proposed, what was resolved and what protests were made, which is evidence that is hard to dispute if a resolution is later challenged.

If the directors do not engage the notary despite a request made in time by shareholders with a sufficient percentage, the resolutions of that meeting are not effective. The prudent course is to record at the meeting itself that the notary was requested and has not attended.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.