What are the rights of a minority shareholder in a limited company?
A minority shareholder in a limited company (“sociedad limitada” or SL) has the same rights as any other shareholder, even though their vote carries less weight. They share in any profits that are distributed, have a pre-emption right to take up new quotas (“participaciones”) when the capital is increased with money, attend the meeting, vote and can ask for information. In addition, the law reserves to the minority certain rights that do not depend on the majority's vote and that are exercised with 1 %, 5 % or 25 % of the capital, depending on the case, or even with no minimum percentage. The articles of association and agreements between shareholders can add further protections.
Alburquerque Abogados
The rights of every shareholder
The Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) gives every shareholder, whatever their percentage, certain minimum rights:
- To share in the distribution of profits and, if the company is liquidated, in the assets that remain.
- To take up new quotas first, in proportion to those already held, when the capital is increased with contributions of money.
- To attend the general meeting and vote at it. In a limited company, the articles of association cannot require a minimum number of quotas in order to attend.
- To ask for information on the matters dealt with at the meeting and to receive the annual accounts before they are approved.
- To inspect the register of members and obtain a certificate of the resolutions and the minutes of meetings.
These rights do not give the minority shareholder the power to decide. Resolutions are adopted by majority and bind all the shareholders, including those who vote against or do not attend.
The rights the law reserves to the minority
To balance that power, the law gives the minority certain rights that the majority cannot deny it. Several shareholders can add their quotas together to reach the percentage each of these rights requires, which are as follows:
- Calling the meeting. Shareholders holding at least 5 % of the capital can serve a formal notarial demand on the directors to call a meeting on the matters they specify, which must be held within the following two months. If the directors do not do so, the meeting can be called by the companies registrar or by the court clerk (“letrado de la Administración de Justicia”), who runs the court office.
- Information and examination of the accounts. If a request for information is supported by 25 % of the capital, the directors cannot refuse it. With 5 %, the documents supporting the annual accounts can be examined at the registered office, unless the articles of association say otherwise.
- Notary at the meeting. With 5 %, a notary can be required to take the minutes of the meeting, if requested five days in advance.
- Auditor. With 5 %, the companies registrar can be asked to appoint an auditor at the company's expense, within three months of the close of the financial year, if the company is not required to be audited.
- Challenging resolutions. With 1 %, resolutions contrary to the law or the articles of association, together with those that harm the company's interest for the benefit of some shareholders or third parties, can be challenged before the judge, generally within one year.
- Right of withdrawal (“derecho de separación”). Any shareholder, with no minimum percentage, can leave the company and be paid the value of their quotas in the cases provided for by law or by the articles of association, including where the meeting does not distribute as dividend at least 25 % of the previous year's profits, subject to the requirements set by law.
- Corporate liability action (“acción social de responsabilidad”). With 5 %, the directors can be sued, in the company's interest, for the harm they have caused it, when the company does not do so.
What the articles of association and agreements can change
The articles of association can strengthen the minority's position, for example by requiring higher majorities for certain resolutions, short of unanimity, or by lowering the percentage needed to challenge a resolution. Shareholders' agreements can go further, although in principle they bind only those who sign them and not the company.
Conversely, some of these rights allow the articles of association to provide otherwise, such as the examination of accounting documents or withdrawal for non-payment of dividends. It is advisable to read them before taking a right for granted.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.