Can a shareholder examine the company's accounting records?
Yes, but with limits, and above all when the meeting that approves the annual accounts is to be held. From the notice of that meeting, any shareholder can obtain from the company, immediately and free of charge, the accounts to be approved and, if they exist, the management report and the auditor's report. In a limited company, in addition, shareholders representing at least 5 % of the capital can examine at the registered office, themselves or with an accounting expert, the documents supporting those accounts, unless the articles of association say otherwise. Outside those cases, the law does not give a shareholder a general right to inspect the books whenever they wish.
Alburquerque Abogados
What any shareholder can ask for
Every shareholder of a limited company, whatever their percentage, can ask the directors for the reports or clarifications they need on the items on the agenda of a meeting. They can do so in writing before the meeting or orally during it. The directors are obliged to reply, unless they consider that disclosing that information harms the company's interest. That refusal is not possible when the request is supported by shareholders representing at least 25 % of the capital.
When the meeting is about to approve the annual accounts, the shareholder also has the right to receive the documents put forward for approval, which are the balance sheet, the profit and loss account, the notes to the accounts and the other statements the company must draw up. If they exist, also the management report and the auditor's report. The company must supply them immediately and free of charge from when the meeting is called. The notice of the meeting must mention this right.
Examining the documents with 5 %
The annual accounts are a summary. To check what lies behind them, the law gives a wider right to the shareholders of a limited company who represent, alone or by adding their quotas (“participaciones”) together, at least 5 % of the capital. Its conditions are these:
- What is examined. The documents that support and underlie the accounts, such as the accounting books, invoices, bank statements or contracts.
- When. From the notice of the meeting that is to approve the accounts until it is held.
- Where and with whom. At the registered office, in person or accompanied by an accounting expert.
The law speaks of examining the documents, not of receiving copies, so it is advisable to attend with the expert and take notes of what is needed. The articles of association can remove or modify this right, so they should be read first. In a public limited company the law does not provide for it.
If the company does not provide the information
It is advisable to request the information in writing and by a means that records the date and content. If you do not receive it, repeat the request at the meeting and ask for it to be recorded in the minutes.
A lack of information allows the resolution to be challenged when what was not provided was essential for an average shareholder to be able to vote or exercise their other rights reasonably. How a resolution is challenged is a separate matter.
Anyone seeking an independent review of the accounts can also ask the companies registrar, if they hold 5 % of the capital and within three months of the close of the financial year, to appoint an auditor at the company's expense when the company is not required to be audited.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.