How can I challenge company resolutions?
By bringing a claim against the company before the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”), which is what the former commercial courts are now called. It can be brought by a shareholder who already was one when the resolution was adopted and who holds, alone or with others, at least 1 % of the capital. The claimant must allege that the resolution is contrary to the law or to the articles of association, or that it harms the interests of the company for the benefit of some shareholders or third parties. The time limit is, as a general rule, one year. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.
Alburquerque Abogados
Which resolutions can be challenged
The law allows three kinds of general meeting resolutions to be challenged:
- Those contrary to the law.
- Those that go against the articles of association or the rules of the general meeting.
- Those that harm the interests of the company for the benefit of one or more shareholders or third parties. This includes abuse of majority, which is a resolution that the majority imposes in its own interest, without any reasonable need of the company and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders.
Not every defect will do. Minor procedural failings do not allow a challenge, unless they affect the form or the time limit of the notice of the meeting, the basic rules for constituting the meeting, the majorities or some other significant point. Incorrect or insufficient information given before the meeting counts only if it was essential for an average shareholder to be able to vote or to exercise their other rights reasonably. The attendance of someone who should not have been there or a miscounted vote count only if they were decisive. Nor can a resolution be challenged if the company has revoked it or validly replaced it with another before the claim was brought. The fact that a resolution breaches a shareholders' agreement is not, on its own, enough to annul it.
Who can challenge
Besides the directors and third parties with a legitimate interest, a shareholder who meets two conditions can bring a challenge:
- Having become a shareholder before the resolution was adopted.
- Holding, alone or by adding their quotas (“participaciones”) to those of other shareholders, at least 1 % of the capital. The articles of association may lower this percentage.
A shareholder who does not reach the percentage cannot ask for the resolution to be declared void but keeps the right to claim for the harm the resolution has caused. If the resolution is contrary to public policy, that is, to the most basic principles of the legal system, any shareholder can challenge it, with no minimum percentage and even if they joined the company later.
It is advisable to vote against and to ask for the opposition to be recorded in the minutes. Formal defects must be raised at the time, because anyone who had the chance to do so and kept silent cannot allege them afterwards.
Where and how the claim is brought
The claim is brought against the company and follows the ordinary proceedings (“juicio ordinario”), with a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”). It is filed with the commercial section of the first-instance court for the company's registered office, which as a general rule has its seat in the provincial capital. If the articles of association submit these disputes to arbitration, they are decided by one or more arbitrators appointed by an arbitral institution instead of by the judge.
While the case is pending, the judge may provisionally suspend the resolution. In companies that are not listed on the stock exchange, claimants holding at least 5 % of the capital can ask for this. If the ground for the challenge can be remedied and the company asks for it, the judge gives it a reasonable period to put it right.
A judgment annulling the resolution applies to all shareholders, even those who did not bring the claim. If the resolution was registered in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”), its registration is cancelled together with that of any later entries that contradict it.
The general time limit for bringing a claim is one year, with rules for calculating it and exceptions that are a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.