What is abuse of majority in a company?

It is a resolution that the majority of the shareholders imposes at the general meeting in its own interest, without it answering a reasonable need of the company and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders. The Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) treats it as a resolution that harms the interests of the company, even if it causes no damage to the company's assets. That is why it can be challenged before the judge. There is no abuse merely because the majority decides something the minority does not like, because deciding by majority is the rule.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The three elements the law requires

In a company, votes decide. The resolutions of the general meeting bind all the shareholders, including those who voted against. The limit is that the majority cannot use that power solely for its own benefit. For there to be abuse, three elements must be present at the same time:

  • That the resolution does not answer a reasonable need of the company. If the measure has a serious business justification, even a debatable one, there is no abuse.
  • That the majority adopts it in its own interest, that is, to obtain an advantage it does not share with the other shareholders.
  • That it causes the other shareholders an unjustified detriment.

The company does not have to suffer harm. A resolution may leave its assets unaffected and still be abusive because of the way it distributes its effects among the shareholders. Whoever alleges the abuse must, in principle, prove it.

The most common examples

The conflicts that arise most often are of three kinds:

  • Dividends. The majority decides year after year to take all the profit to reserves without the company needing it, while the shareholders who make up the majority are paid by the company in other ways, such as salaries or director's remuneration.
  • Capital increases. An increase that the company does not need is approved, or on terms designed so that the minority cannot take part, with the aim of reducing its percentage.
  • Remuneration and contracts with the majority shareholders. Disproportionate salaries are approved for the directors who make up the majority, or contracts between them and the company on terms worse for the company than market terms.

Each case depends on its circumstances. Keeping profits to pay debts or finance investment, or increasing capital because the company needs funds, are legitimate decisions even if the minority does not like them.

What the consequences are

An abusive resolution can be challenged so that the judge annuls it. In disputes over dividends, the courts have annulled abusive resolutions not to distribute profits and, where the general meeting had no room to decide otherwise, have gone so far as to order distribution. Who can challenge, how and within what time limit is a separate matter. The failure to distribute dividends also has a remedy of its own, which is the shareholder's right to withdraw from the company when, subject to the requirements the law sets, the general meeting does not distribute at least 25 % of the profits of the previous financial year.

The law does not expressly regulate the opposite case, that of the minority that blocks necessary resolutions for no reason. The courts assess it under the general rules of good faith and abuse of rights.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.