Can a capital increase be used to force out a shareholder?
A capital increase does not force anyone out. What it can do is dilute, that is, reduce the percentage of a shareholder who does not take part in it. The law protects that shareholder with the pre-emption right, which allows them to take up the new quotas (“participaciones”) that are due to them and keep their percentage when the increase is paid for in cash. If the increase does not answer a reasonable need of the company and the majority imposes it in its own interest, to the unjustified detriment of the shareholder, the shareholder can challenge it for abuse of majority. Genuinely excluding a shareholder requires a ground for exclusion provided for in the law or in the articles of association, which is a separate matter.
Alburquerque Abogados
Diluting is not forcing out
The general meeting can approve the increase with the majority the law requires to amend the articles of association. In a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) that is more than half the votes of all the quotas (“participaciones”), unless the articles require a higher majority. The minority shareholder cannot prevent it with their vote, but nobody obliges them to put in money.
A shareholder who does not take part remains a shareholder, with a smaller percentage. The consequences can be serious. Their share of the dividends falls. They may also drop below the percentages that give rights to the minority, such as the 5 % needed to ask for the general meeting to be called or for a notary or an auditor to be appointed. If the new quotas are created at the nominal value shown in the articles of association and the company is worth more, a shareholder who does not take part also loses value.
There is one operation on the capital that can leave out a shareholder who does not take part. It is the reduction of the capital to zero with a simultaneous increase, which is used to absorb losses. A shareholder who does not take part in that increase ceases to be a shareholder, but the law requires their pre-emption right to be respected in every case.
The limits that protect the shareholder
The law sets several limits on a capital increase that is used against the minority:
- The pre-emption right. In capital increases paid for in cash, each shareholder can take up a number of new quotas in proportion to those they already hold. The period for doing so cannot be shorter than one month.
- The requirements for removing that right. The general meeting can exclude it only when the interests of the company require it and, in a limited company, with the favourable vote of at least two thirds of the votes of all the quotas. It also takes a report from the directors justifying the exclusion and stating to whom the quotas will be allocated. The notice of the meeting must announce it. The new quotas must be created at their real value, which may be higher than the nominal value.
- The limits on a capital increase by set-off of claims, which turns into capital what the company owes to a shareholder or a third party. There is no pre-emption right in this case, but in a limited company the claims must be fully quantified and due. The directors must explain them in a report, available to the shareholders from the notice of the meeting, confirming that they match the accounts.
- Abuse of majority. Even if the formalities are complied with, the increase can be annulled if it does not answer a reasonable need of the company and the majority adopts it in its own interest and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders.
There is no pre-emption right either when what is contributed is not money, such as a property. In that case the directors must describe and value the contribution in a report.
What it is advisable to do
Read the notice of the meeting and the reports as soon as you receive them and ask for any missing information on what the money will be used for and the value given to the quotas. Consider whether it is in your interest to take part in the increase in order to keep your percentage. If you vote against, ask for your opposition to be recorded in the minutes.
If you decide to challenge the resolution, bear in mind that the general time limit is one year and that the law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.