How can a shareholder be expelled from a limited company?

Only on the grounds set by law or by the articles of association, never by the mere wish of the majority. Expulsion, which the law calls exclusion, requires a resolution of the general meeting passed with at least two thirds of the votes, after deducting the quotas (“participaciones”) of the shareholder concerned, who cannot vote. If that shareholder holds 25 % or more of the capital and does not accept the exclusion, a final judgment is also required. The excluded shareholder is entitled to be paid the fair value of their quotas.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The grounds

The law allows a limited company to exclude a shareholder in three cases:

  • When the shareholder wilfully fails to perform an ancillary obligation, which is an obligation other than the capital contribution that the articles of association impose on all or some of the shareholders, such as working for the company.
  • When the shareholder is a director and breaches the ban on competing with the company.
  • When the shareholder is a director and has been ordered by a final judgment to compensate the company for damage caused by acts contrary to the law or the articles of association, or carried out without due diligence.

The articles of association may add other grounds, such as ceasing to work for the company or competing with it without being a director. They must be specific and have been incorporated into the articles of association with the consent of all the shareholders.

Outside those grounds there is no expulsion. A shareholder cannot be excluded for disagreeing, for voting against or for breaching a shareholders' agreement that is not set out in the articles of association. Increasing the capital does not expel anyone either. It may reduce a shareholder's percentage, but that is another matter.

The procedure

Exclusion is decided at a general meeting. The shareholder concerned may attend but does not vote. Their quotas are deducted to calculate the majority, which is at least two thirds of the remaining votes. The minutes must record who voted in favour.

What happens next depends on the excluded shareholder's percentage:

  • If the shareholder holds less than 25 % of the capital, the resolution of the meeting is enough. If they disagree, it is for them to go to the judge against the resolution.
  • If the shareholder holds 25 % or more and does not accept the exclusion, the resolution is not enough. The company must sue them and obtain a final judgment confirming it. If the company does not file the claim within one month of the resolution, any shareholder who voted in favour may do so in its name.

The exception is the shareholder-director ordered to compensate the company, who can be excluded without that second judgment even if they hold 25 % or more. Claims are filed with the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”). The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.

What the excluded shareholder is paid

Exclusion does not leave the shareholder with nothing. They are entitled to receive the fair value of their quotas. If there is no agreement on that value, it is fixed by an independent expert appointed by the companies registrar for the registered office, at the request of the company or the shareholder. The expert's fees are paid by the company, which may deduct from the excluded shareholder the share corresponding to their percentage of the capital. The company must pay within two months of receiving the expert's report. The quotas are then cancelled by a capital reduction, unless the meeting has resolved that the company itself acquire them. How that value is calculated is another matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.