What happens if two shareholders cannot agree?
If each shareholder holds half the capital and they vote in opposite directions, the resolution is not passed, because neither reaches a majority. The company carries on with the directors it has, but it cannot take the decisions that depend on the general meeting, such as approving the accounts or changing a director. The way out lies in negotiating, in one buying the other's share or in whatever has been provided for in the articles of association or in a shareholders' agreement. If the deadlock permanently prevents the company from functioning, its dissolution remains as a last resort.
Alburquerque Abogados
Why the company becomes deadlocked
In a limited company (“sociedad limitada” or SL), the resolutions of the general meeting are passed by a majority of the votes cast, provided that the majority represents at least one third of all the votes in the company. Amending the articles of association or increasing the capital requires more than half of all the votes. Other resolutions, such as a merger, require two thirds. The articles of association may raise those majorities, short of unanimity.
With two shareholders at 50 %, one shareholder's vote against prevents any of those majorities from being reached, but only if it is cast. If that shareholder does not attend the meeting or abstains, the other passes the ordinary resolutions, such as the accounts or the appointment of a director, with their 50 %. If one of the two holds more than half of the votes, they can pass those resolutions alone, but the deadlock reappears in resolutions for which the law or the articles of association require a majority that can only be reached with both votes.
While the disagreement lasts, the company is not left without direction. In a limited company the directors hold office for an indefinite period, unless the articles of association set a term, so whoever is a director continues to manage the day-to-day business. What comes to a halt is everything that depends on the general meeting. If the two shareholders are also directors acting jointly (“mancomunados”), meaning that they must act together, the deadlock reaches the daily management as well.
The ways out
The law gives neither of them a casting vote and does not allow one to force the other to sell. The usual ways out are these:
- Negotiating an agreement on the point in dispute or on the division of roles, with the help of a mediator if necessary.
- One buying the other's quotas (“participaciones”). Between shareholders the sale is free, unless the articles of association say otherwise. The difficulty usually lies in the price, which can be entrusted to an independent expert chosen by both.
- Both selling their quotas to a third party.
- Applying what the articles of association or the shareholders' agreement provide, if this was thought of when the company was set up.
If none of this is possible and the meeting is paralysed to the point that the company cannot function, the law provides for dissolution as a last resort, which can be requested from the judge and which means winding up the company.
What is worth agreeing beforehand
Deadlock is resolved much better if it was provided for when the shareholders still got on. The most common mechanisms are the following:
- A forced buy-sell clause. Faced with a persistent disagreement, one shareholder offers a price and the other chooses between buying or selling at that price.
- Call or put options in favour of one shareholder or the other in the event of deadlock.
- A right of withdrawal (“derecho de separación”), which lets a shareholder leave and be paid the value of their quotas, or a ground for exclusion. To bind the company they must be set out in the articles of association, which requires the consent of all the shareholders. The exclusion of a shareholder who holds 25 % or more of the capital and does not accept it also requires a final judgment.
- A commitment to go to mediation or arbitration, or to accept, on specific matters, the decision of a third party trusted by both.
A shareholders' agreement binds those who sign it but, in principle, not the company. That is why anything that has to work within the company, such as majorities or grounds for withdrawal, should also be taken into the articles of association.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.