How to split a company between shareholders?
If the shareholders want to part ways and each keep a part of the business, the route the law offers is a demerger, which divides the company's assets and liabilities between two or more companies. For each shareholder to end up alone in their own company, the quotas (“participaciones”) are allocated differently from the proportion each one held, which requires the individual consent of the shareholders affected. If there is no agreement, neither of them can impose the division on the other and other ways out remain, such as one buying out the other. It is advisable first to value each part and to provide for what happens to the debts, because each company may have to answer for earlier debts allocated to the other if the other does not pay them.
Alburquerque Abogados
Splitting the company through a demerger
If the question is how to allocate the quotas (“participaciones”) when setting up a company, that depends on what each shareholder contributes and is a separate matter. Here the question concerns shareholders who no longer want to carry on together and would each rather keep a part of the business than sell.
The assets belong to the company, not to the shareholders, so they cannot be divided up as if they were jointly owned. What the law allows is to divide the company itself through a demerger, which transfers each part of its assets and liabilities en bloc, with the property, debts and contracts that make it up, to another company. There are two ways of approaching it:
- A full demerger. The company disappears and its assets and liabilities are divided between two or more companies, new or already existing. Each shareholder, or each group of shareholders, receives the quotas of one of them.
- A partial demerger. The company continues to exist in the hands of one of the shareholders and transfers to another company the part of the business taken by the other shareholder, who receives the quotas of that company and ceases to be a shareholder of the first. The part that leaves must form an economic unit, such as an establishment or a business line capable of operating on its own.
The agreement required
As each shareholder receives the quotas of only one company, the allocation is not proportional. For that reason, in addition to the resolution of the general meeting, which in a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) requires at least two thirds of the votes attaching to all the quotas, every shareholder who does not receive quotas in all the companies receiving the assets and liabilities has to give their individual consent. In practice, the division is only possible if everyone agrees. If they do and approve it at a universal meeting (“junta universal”), it can be carried out without first publishing the draft terms or preparing the directors' report for the shareholders.
If there is no agreement, no shareholder can impose this division. Other ways out remain, such as one buying the other's quotas, both selling to a third party or, if the company is deadlocked on a lasting basis, its dissolution, which is the last resort.
What should be settled beforehand
The draft terms of demerger must state which assets, which debts and which contracts go to each company and on what basis the quotas are allocated. It is advisable to agree on these points beforehand:
- The value of each part. If what each shareholder takes does not match their percentage in the company, it must be agreed how the difference is to be made up.
- The debts. Each one goes to the company named in the draft terms. But if the company that has to pay a debt incurred before the draft terms, which had not yet fallen due when they were published, does not pay it, the creditor can claim it from the other companies involved, each up to the net value of what it received or retained. That liability becomes time-barred after five years. It is therefore advisable to agree that each company will reimburse the other for anything the latter has to pay for debts that were not its own.
- Contracts and financing. Loans, leases and contracts with customers and suppliers pass to the company to which they are allocated, but some of them provide for what happens in transactions of this kind and should be reviewed.
The tax and employment effects of the division are a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.