How to dissolve a limited company if a shareholder refuses?

It depends on the votes each shareholder holds. Voluntary dissolution is resolved by the general meeting with the votes in favour of more than half of the votes of all the quotas (“participaciones”), unless the articles of association require a higher majority, so whoever holds that majority can dissolve the company even if another shareholder objects. If that majority is not reached, dissolution is possible only where there is a ground laid down by law or by the articles of association, such as deadlock of the company's governing bodies, which is common in companies with two 50 % shareholders. In that case, if the meeting does not resolve to dissolve the company, any shareholder may ask the judge for it. Without that majority and without one of those grounds, a shareholder cannot impose closure on the others.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Majorities at the general meeting

The majority required depends on the reason for the dissolution:

  • If the shareholders want to close the company without the law requiring it, the resolution requires the same as an amendment of the articles of association. In a limited company this is the votes in favour of more than half of the votes of all the quotas (“participaciones”). The articles of association may ask for a higher majority, but not unanimity.
  • If there is a ground for dissolution laid down by law or by the articles of association, the ordinary majority is enough, that is, more votes in favour than against, provided that the votes in favour represent at least one third of all the votes.

The statutory grounds include the cessation of the activity for more than a year, losses that reduce net assets to less than half of the share capital and deadlock of the company's governing bodies where it makes their functioning impossible.

A shareholder left in the minority cannot veto a valid resolution. They keep their rights in the liquidation, including the right to receive their share of what remains after the debts are paid.

If neither has the majority

Where two shareholders, or two groups of shareholders, hold half of the votes each, neither reaches the majority needed to dissolve. If the disagreement goes so far as to prevent the general meeting or the management body from functioning on a lasting basis, for example because the accounts cannot be approved or directors appointed, that deadlock is in itself a statutory ground for dissolution. The steps are these:

  • Ask the directors to call the general meeting to resolve on the dissolution. Any shareholder who believes the ground exists may ask. The directors have two months to call it.
  • If the meeting is not called, is not held or does not adopt the resolution, ask the judge for the dissolution. Any interested party may do so. The directors themselves are obliged to ask for it within two months.

A minority shareholder who wants to leave when no ground for dissolution exists cannot force the closure. The ways out are different, such as selling their quotas or withdrawing from the company in the cases the law provides for, which are a separate matter.

Dissolution by the court

The application is made to the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”) for the company's registered office, with a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”). It is handled as a non-contentious proceeding (“jurisdicción voluntaria”), a simpler procedure than a trial, for which the law does not require the prior attempt to reach an agreement (“MASC”) that it demands before claims. The applicant must show that the ground exists and that they have notified the company of the application. The court summons the directors and the other interested parties to a hearing and decides by order. If it declares the company dissolved, the same order appoints the liquidators and is registered at the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”).

Judges order it when the deadlock is real and lasting, not in the face of a one-off disagreement. As dissolution leads to the liquidation of the company and makes the business disappear, it is advisable to consider beforehand whether another way out is possible, for example one shareholder buying the other's share.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.