How is the value of company quotas calculated?

There is no statutory formula and no single value. In a sale, the price is whatever buyer and seller agree. Where the law requires a shareholder to be paid their share, as when they withdraw from the company or are excluded from it, what is paid is the fair value, which is roughly the price the quotas would fetch in a normal sale between independent parties. If the company and the shareholder cannot agree, it is set by an independent expert appointed by the companies registrar. Neither the nominal value nor the book value is, as a rule, equal to the fair value.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Three values not to be confused

The same quotas (“participaciones”) can be given three very different values:

  • The nominal value. This is the part of the share capital that each quota represents. It appears in the articles. It is a reference figure that does not change even if the company gains or loses value.
  • The book value, or theoretical value. It results from dividing the net assets on the balance sheet, which are the difference between what the company has and what it owes, by the number of quotas. It is often lower than what a working business is worth, because the balance sheet does not capture, for example, the customer base or the rise in value of properties.
  • The fair value. This is the one the law uses when a shareholder has to be paid. It takes into account the company's assets at current prices and its capacity to generate profits.

Who sets it in each case

It depends on the reason the quotas need to be valued:

  • In a voluntary sale, the price is agreed by the parties. If the other shareholders exercise their right of first refusal under the rule in the law, they buy at the price the seller notified to the company.
  • If a shareholder withdraws from the company or is excluded from it, the company and the shareholder can agree the value, or the person who will calculate it and the procedure. If there is no agreement, either of them can ask the companies registrar for the registered office to appoint an independent expert. The expert has two months to issue a report and the company has a further two months from receiving it to pay.
  • If a shareholder dies and the articles give the other shareholders the right to acquire their quotas, they are paid for in cash at their fair value on the day of death.

The fees of the expert appointed by the registrar are paid by the company. In an exclusion, the company may deduct from the excluded shareholder the part that corresponds to their percentage of the capital.

The articles can set in advance the criteria for calculating the value, provided all the shareholders have approved them. What they cannot do is entrust the company's auditor with valuing the quotas being transferred.

How fair value is calculated

The law does not impose a method. The expert chooses the one that best fits the company and often combines several. The most commonly used start from the company's assets, with its property valued at current prices and its debts deducted, from the profits or the cash it is expected to generate in the coming years, or from the prices paid for similar businesses. In a company that only owns properties, the assets weigh more. In a going concern, what it is able to earn weighs more.

To do the work, the expert can ask the company for any information and documents they consider useful. Anyone who disagrees with the valuation can, in principle, challenge it before a judge, although the law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before a claim is brought.

The value given to quotas for calculating taxes follows its own rules and is a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.