When does a shareholder have a right of withdrawal because no dividends are paid?

When the general meeting does not resolve to distribute as a dividend at least 25 % of the profits of the previous financial year that the law allows to be distributed. It is also necessary that the fifth financial year since the company's registration in the Companies Registry has passed, that there have been profits in the three preceding financial years and that the shareholder has had their protest at the inadequacy of the dividend recorded in the minutes. The right does not arise if, over the last five years, at least 25 % of the distributable profits of that period has been distributed in total. The time limit for withdrawing is one month from the annual general meeting. The articles of association may exclude or modify this right.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The requirements, one by one

The law does not directly impose an annual dividend. Article 348 bis of the Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) works in practice as a minimum, because it allows the shareholder to leave and be paid the value of their quotas (“participaciones”) if nothing is distributed and all of these requirements are met:

  • That the fifth financial year counted from the company's registration in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) has passed.
  • That the company has made profits during the three preceding financial years.
  • That the general meeting does not resolve to distribute as a dividend at least 25 % of the profits made in the previous financial year that are legally distributable. These are the profits the law allows to be distributed once the compulsory reserves have been set aside and, where applicable, losses from previous years have been offset.
  • That the shareholder has had their protest at the inadequacy of the dividend recorded in the minutes of the meeting.

If the distributable profit of the previous financial year was 100.000 euros, the dividend resolved on has to reach 25.000 euros for the right not to arise.

The protest is essential. A shareholder who neither attends the meeting nor is represented at it cannot make it and will not be able to withdraw on this ground. It is advisable to vote against the proposal for the allocation of the profit and to ask expressly for the protest to be included in the minutes.

When there is no right of withdrawal

Even if the minimum is not distributed that year, the right does not exist in these cases:

  • If the total of the dividends distributed over the last five years amounts to at least 25 % of the legally distributable profits of that period. If over those five years the distributable profits added up to 400.000 euros and 100.000 or more was distributed, there is no right of withdrawal even if nothing is distributed this year.
  • If the articles of association have excluded or modified this right. Removing or modifying it requires the consent of all the shareholders, unless the right to withdraw is recognised for any shareholder who does not vote in favour.
  • If the company is listed on the stock exchange or on a multilateral trading facility, is a sports public limited company (“sociedad anónima deportiva”) or is one of the financial institutions that the law excludes, such as credit institutions.
  • If the company is in insolvency proceedings or has notified the court that it is negotiating with its creditors under the insolvency legislation. The law also excludes a company that has reached a refinancing agreement protected by that legislation, an instrument that the 2022 insolvency reform replaced with restructuring plans without this article having been adapted.

In groups required to draw up consolidated accounts, the shareholder of the parent company has a similar right, calculated on the consolidated results.

How it is exercised and what comes next

The time limit is one month from the date on which the annual general meeting was held, which is the one that approves the accounts and decides what is to be done with the profit. Within that period the shareholder must notify the company in writing that they are withdrawing. It is advisable to do so by “burofax” (a certified letter with proof of content) or by notarial demand, so that the content and the date are on record.

The company must then pay the fair value of the quotas. If there is no agreement on that value, it is fixed by an independent expert appointed by the companies registrar, whose fees are paid by the company. If the company denies the right or does not pay, it has to be claimed before the court. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.

The right of withdrawal does not rule out a challenge to the resolution that denies the dividend, for example for abuse of majority, nor a claim for liability against the directors.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.