Is it compulsory to distribute dividends?
No, the law does not require a company to distribute profits every year. It is for the general meeting to decide by majority when it approves the accounts and resolves how the result is to be applied, and it may leave the profit in the company as reserves. But that freedom has two limits. If the general meeting does not resolve to distribute at least 25 % of the previous financial year's profits that the law allows to be distributed, a shareholder who meets the legal requirements may withdraw from the company and receive the fair value of their quotas (“participaciones”). In addition, a resolution not to distribute may be annulled if the majority imposes it abusively.
Alburquerque Abogados
Who decides and when distribution is compulsory
Every shareholder has the right to share in the company's profits, but that right does not allow them to demand a dividend every year. It is for the general meeting to decide, when it approves the accounts, whether the profit is distributed, transferred to reserves or used to offset losses. Only when the general meeting resolves on a distribution does a specific right to be paid arise for the shareholder. Leaving profits in the company can be reasonable, for example to finance investment or repay debt.
There are cases where distribution is compulsory. The articles of association may fix a minimum dividend, which then binds the general meeting. If the company has non-voting quotas (“participaciones”), it must resolve on the minimum dividend that the articles of association give them whenever there are distributable profits. The same applies to quotas with a preferential dividend, unless the articles of association say otherwise. Shareholders may also commit to a minimum distribution in a shareholders' agreement, which binds those who sign it but, in principle, not the company.
The 25 % minimum distribution and the right of withdrawal
The Spanish Companies Act (“Ley de Sociedades de Capital”) does not impose a dividend, but it gives the shareholder a way out when the company makes money and does not distribute it. Once the fifth financial year since the company's entry in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) has passed, if the general meeting does not resolve to distribute as a dividend at least 25 % of the previous financial year's profits that are legally distributable, a shareholder who has had a protest about the inadequacy of the dividend recorded in the minutes has a right of withdrawal (“derecho de separación”). To withdraw is to leave the company and receive from it the fair value of one's quotas. In practice, that 25 % works as the minimum distribution the company has to resolve on if it wants to prevent the dissenting shareholder from leaving with their share.
The right has further conditions. Among others, the company must have made a profit in each of the three preceding financial years and the shareholder has one month from the annual general meeting, the one that approves the accounts, in which to exercise it. It does not arise if in the last five years at least 25 % of the distributable profits of that period has already been distributed. The articles of association may remove or modify it, which requires the consent of all the shareholders or recognition of the right to withdraw for anyone who does not vote in favour. The law also excludes it in some companies, such as listed companies or those in insolvency proceedings (the “concurso de acreedores”).
When not distributing is an abuse of the majority
Even if the requirements for withdrawal are not met, or even if the shareholder prefers to stay in the company, a resolution not to distribute may be challenged if it is abusive. The law regards as abusive a resolution that the majority adopts in its own interest and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders, without it responding to a reasonable need of the company. An example is a company that accumulates reserves year after year without needing them while the majority shareholders are paid by other means, such as their remuneration as directors.
The courts have annulled resolutions of this kind and, where the general meeting had no room left to decide otherwise, have gone as far as ordering the distribution. The right of withdrawal does not close off this route, because the law preserves the actions for challenge and for liability. The time limit for a challenge is one year, with exceptions. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
For the company, the prudent course is for the minutes of the general meeting to record the reasons why the profit is being retained.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.