How does the right of first refusal work in a limited company?
It is the right of the other shareholders, or of the company itself where so provided, to take the quotas that a shareholder wants to transfer to someone else, ahead of that person. It works as the articles say, since they almost always regulate it. If they say nothing, the rule in the law applies, under which the shareholder notifies the directors of their intention, the general meeting decides and the shareholders who wish to buy have priority on the same terms. If within three months the company does not tell the shareholder who is buying, the shareholder may sell to the person they had announced.
Alburquerque Abogados
When it applies
In a limited company (“sociedad limitada” or SL), the law does not allow quotas (“participaciones”) to be sold freely to anyone and leaves it to the articles to regulate how the entry of new shareholders is controlled. Most often they give the shareholders a right of first refusal, also known as “tanteo”. The articles then say which transfers it applies to, within what period it is exercised and how the price is set.
Unless the articles say otherwise, transfers between shareholders and those made to a spouse, an ascendant, a descendant or a company in the same group are free. But the articles can also make these transfers subject to the priority of the other shareholders, so it is worth reading them before selling or giving to a relative.
The articles have limits. They cannot make the transfer practically free or prohibit it, except for a maximum of five years from the incorporation of the company or if they give the shareholder the right to withdraw from it at any time, that is, to leave it and be paid the value of their quotas.
The procedure laid down by law
Where the articles do not regulate transfers to other persons, the law lays down these rules:
- The shareholder notifies the directors in writing how many quotas they wish to transfer, to whom, at what price and on what terms.
- The general meeting decides, without the shareholder who wishes to transfer voting. It can refuse consent only if it notifies the shareholder, through a notary, who will acquire all the quotas offered.
- The shareholders who attend that meeting have priority to buy. If there are several, they divide the quotas in proportion to their share of the capital. If no shareholder wants them, nor a third party accepted by the meeting, the meeting can resolve that the company itself buys them.
- Whoever exercises the priority buys at the price and on the terms the shareholder notified. If payment was deferred, a credit institution must guarantee it.
- The deed is signed within one month of the company notifying who is buying.
- If three months pass from the shareholder notifying their intention without the company saying who is buying, the shareholder may transfer the quotas on the terms announced.
If what is planned is not a sale but, for example, a gift, the price paid by whoever exercises the priority is the one agreed with the shareholder and, failing agreement, the fair value of the quotas on the day of the notice. That value is set by an independent expert, other than the company's auditor, appointed by the directors.
If it is not followed
A transfer made without following the law or the articles has no effect against the company, which can refuse to recognise the person who acquired as a shareholder. That is why, before signing before a notary, it is advisable to have the resolution of the general meeting or a certificate from the director confirming that nobody exercised the priority within the period.
The right of first refusal can also appear in a shareholders' agreement, which is a contract between the shareholders separate from the articles. In that case it binds only those who signed it. Any breach is dealt with between them, not against the company.
Inheritance and attachment of quotas have their own rules. The effect that a gift of quotas to a child later has on the estate of the person who made the gift is also a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.