What should a shareholders' agreement include?
The law does not require a shareholders' agreement to be signed or say what it must contain. It is a contract between all or some of the shareholders that supplements the articles with rules that they do not contain, or cannot contain in the same detail. It usually regulates how important decisions are taken, how people join and leave the company, what each shareholder contributes and receives and what happens if someone is in breach. A private document signed by the shareholders is enough, although it binds only those who sign it.
Alburquerque Abogados
What it usually regulates
Each agreement is tailor-made, but almost all deal with these matters:
- Governance of the company. Who manages it, how the directors are appointed and removed and which decisions need a higher majority than usual or the agreement of particular shareholders, such as borrowing above a set figure or selling the main assets.
- Transfer of quotas (“participaciones”). A minimum holding period, the right of the other shareholders to buy before a third party and the rules for selling the company together, known as drag-along and tag-along rights, which oblige or allow the other shareholders to sell at the same time.
- A shareholder's exit. In which cases they may or must leave the company, how their quotas are valued and within what period they are paid.
- Money. What contributions each shareholder undertakes to make if the company needs financing, on what basis profits will be distributed and how the shareholders who run the company are paid.
- Personal commitments. Each shareholder's time commitment, the prohibition on competing with the company and the duty of confidentiality.
- Disagreements. How to break a deadlock between shareholders and whether disputes will go to mediation or arbitration.
- Breach. Normally a financial penalty and, sometimes, the right of the others to buy the quotas of the party in breach.
Form and who is bound
The agreement needs no notary and is not registered in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”), so its content is confidential. The articles, by contrast, can be consulted by anyone. Signing it before a notary has the advantage of leaving secure proof of the date and of who signed it.
Like any contract, it binds those who sign it and no one else. The law says that confidential agreements between shareholders cannot be enforced against the company. Someone who later buys quotas or joins the company in a capital increase is bound only if they adhere to the agreement. That is why it is advisable to provide that no shareholder transfers their quotas unless the buyer signs it.
What should also go into the articles
Some rules are valid against the company and against future shareholders only if they appear in the registered articles. This is the case for restrictions on the transfer of quotas, for enhanced majorities in the general meeting and for the grounds on which a shareholder may withdraw or be excluded. The prudent course is to put these rules into the articles, within the limits of the law. The more personal or confidential commitments can stay in the agreement.
The limits are not the same. The articles of a limited company (“sociedad limitada”), for example, cannot require unanimity to adopt resolutions at the general meeting. In the agreement, by contrast, the shareholders can commit not to vote on a decision without the agreement of all.
The agreement should also say what the shareholders will do if it comes to contradict the articles. The usual course is for them to undertake to vote at the general meeting for whatever is needed to adapt them.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.