When can a shareholder request an audit?

In a company that is not required to have its accounts audited, shareholders holding at least 5 % of the capital can ask for an audit. The request is made to the companies registrar for the company's registered office before three months have passed since the end of the financial year to be reviewed. If the company has not already appointed an auditor whose report the shareholder is assured of receiving, the registrar appoints one and the company pays the fees. If the company is required to have its accounts audited and the general meeting has not appointed an auditor in time, any shareholder can ask for one to be appointed, with no minimum percentage.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The right of the 5 % minority

Most small companies do not have to have their accounts audited. In those companies, the law allows the minority to obtain an independent review without depending on the vote of the general meeting. The requirements are these:

  • Hold, alone or by adding together the quotas (“participaciones”) of several shareholders, at least 5 % of the share capital.
  • Submit the request to the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”) for the company's registered office before three months have passed since the financial year-end. If the financial year coincides with the calendar year, the deadline ends on 31 March.
  • Ask for a review of the annual accounts for that financial year, which is the last one closed.

There is no need to allege or prove any irregularity. The auditor checks whether the accounts give a true and fair view of the company's assets, financial position and results.

How the request is processed

The request is made in writing and states who is submitting it, which company it concerns and which financial year is to be audited. It must be accompanied by documents showing that the applicant is a shareholder and with what percentage, such as the deed by which the quotas were acquired.

The registrar passes the request on to the company, which has five days to object. It can do so only with documents proving that the appointment is not appropriate, or by denying that the applicant is a shareholder or holds the required percentage. The most common ground is that the company shows that it has already appointed an auditor of its own for that financial year and that the shareholder is assured of receiving the report, because the appointment is registered in the Companies Registry or because the report is delivered to the shareholder. In that case the request is rejected, since the review the shareholder is seeking is already covered. The registrar's decision can be appealed within fifteen days to the “Dirección General de Seguridad Jurídica y Fe Pública”, the Spanish authority overseeing the registries and notaries.

The auditor is appointed by the registrar, not by the shareholder or the company. The registrar also sets the auditor's remuneration, which is paid by the company.

What effects it has and what other routes there are

Once the auditor has been appointed at the minority's request, the company cannot file the accounts for that financial year with the Companies Registry without the auditor's report. If the general meeting approved them before the auditor had finished, it will have to approve them again in order to file them. The report is one of the documents that any shareholder can ask for from the moment the meeting is called.

Once the three months have passed, a narrower route remains. Anyone who shows a legitimate interest can ask the companies registrar or the court clerk (“letrado de la Administración de Justicia”), who runs the court office, for an audit, but must advance its cost. The company reimburses it if the auditor disclaims an opinion or gives an adverse one. If the opinion is unqualified, the person who asked for the audit pays. If the auditor gives a qualified opinion, how the cost is shared is decided case by case. This route does not succeed either if an auditor was already registered for that financial year.

In companies required by law to have their accounts audited, the general meeting must appoint the auditor before the end of the financial year to be audited. If it does not, the directors or any shareholder can ask the companies registrar to appoint one.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.