Can an older person be placed in a care home without their consent?

If the older person can make decisions for themselves, no one can place them in a care home against their will, not even their children, although the children may believe it is best for them. If an illness affecting their faculties, such as advanced dementia, prevents them from deciding, admission without their consent is an involuntary admission (“internamiento no voluntario”) and requires the judge's authorisation, which as a rule must be given beforehand. Only in an emergency can it go ahead without waiting for that authorisation. The facility must then notify the court within twenty-four hours, so that the judge can confirm the admission or set it aside within a maximum of seventy-two hours. A relative's signature is no substitute for the judge's decision.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

If the person is able to decide

The law protects each person's freedom to decide where they live. As long as the older person understands their situation and can express what they want, the decision to move into a care home is theirs, even if the family is worried about them continuing to live alone at home. Age or a diagnosis does not, on its own, take that right away from them.

What the family can do is talk to them and suggest other solutions that are acceptable to them, such as home care or a day centre. If they are admitted of their own free will, the admission does not require court authorisation.

If they moved in voluntarily and later become unable to decide whether to stay, the situation changes. In Catalonia, the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, requires the director of the facility to notify the court of the case of anyone who was admitted voluntarily because of a mental disorder and can no longer decide whether to remain, so that the judge can rule on it. For care homes for older people, the “Fiscalía General del Estado”, the Spanish Attorney General's Office, in a circular addressed to prosecutors throughout Spain, takes the view that dementia developing after admission makes the admission involuntary, so that it then requires the judge's oversight.

If the person is unable to decide

When an illness prevents the person from deciding for themselves, admission without their consent restricts their liberty and therefore requires the judge's authorisation. The person does not have to object. It is enough that they are not in a position to decide. This is laid down by the “Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil”, Spain's Civil Procedure Act, for the whole of Spain. The Catalan Civil Code expressly says so for anyone who has a mental disorder or an illness affecting their cognitive capacity, whatever their age. The Spanish Attorney General's Office, relying on judgments of the “Tribunal Constitucional”, Spain's Constitutional Court, considers that this safeguard extends to admission to a care home for older people.

Authorisation is sought from the court for the place where the person lives. Before deciding, the judge must hear the person and the Public Prosecutor's Office (“Ministerio Fiscal”), examine the person personally and hear the opinion of a doctor of the judge's own choosing. The judge may also hear other people, such as family members. The person can be defended by a lawyer of their own. If they do not appoint one, they are defended by the Public Prosecutor's Office or, depending on the case, by a court-appointed representative (“defensor judicial”).

If the judge authorises the admission, those caring for the person at the facility must report to the judge periodically on whether it is still necessary. When it no longer is, the person is discharged and the court is informed.

Emergency admissions

Admission can take place without prior authorisation only when an emergency does not allow any delay. In Catalonia, a doctor must confirm that emergency, which must be based on an immediate and serious risk to the person's health or to the physical or mental integrity of the person or of others.

In that case, the director of the facility must notify the court of the admission within the following twenty-four hours. That notification is the director's responsibility, not the family's or social services'. The judge must confirm the admission or set it aside within a maximum of seventy-two hours of receiving the notification, with the same safeguards of a hearing, an examination and a medical opinion. If these time limits and safeguards are not respected, the admission infringes the person's right to liberty.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.