What happens if the father does not acknowledge the child?

Until paternity is determined, the child legally has only a mother and cannot claim anything from their biological father, neither maintenance nor an inheritance. But acknowledgement is not the only route, because paternity can be declared by a court. This can be sought by the child at any time during their life and, while the child is a minor, by the mother on the child's behalf or by the Public Prosecutor's Office (“Ministerio Fiscal”). Any evidence is admissible at trial and, if the defendant refuses without justification to undergo a biological test, the court can declare him the father where there is other evidence pointing to paternity. Once paternity has been declared, the father has the obligations of any father, although if he opposed the claim, the child can ask for the legal parentage to confer no rights on him.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Until paternity is determined

If the father does not acknowledge the child, the only parentage recorded in the “Registro Civil”, the Civil Register, is the mother's, which is what determines the child's surnames. Legally there is no father, so the child cannot claim maintenance from him and will not inherit from him. Nor does he have any rights over the child.

There is an intermediate route. If the father has acknowledged his paternity in a document that leaves no room for doubt, or if the child has been continuously treated as his by the father himself or by his family, the Civil Register can open a file and register the paternity, provided that neither the Public Prosecutor's Office nor any interested party objects. If there is an objection, court proceedings are the only option left.

The paternity claim

In Catalonia, the child can claim paternity at any time during their life. While the child is a minor, the claim can be brought on their behalf by the mother or by the Public Prosecutor's Office. If the father has died, the claim is brought against his heirs. There is no need to try to reach an agreement before suing, because the law exempts parentage proceedings from that requirement.

Any evidence is admissible at trial. The law presumes that a man is the father if he lived with the mother or had sexual relations with her at the time of conception, or if he treated the child as his own, although these presumptions give way to other evidence. A biological test is usually what decides the case. The law does not provide for anyone to be forced to undergo one, but if the defendant refuses without justification, the court can declare him the father where there is other evidence of paternity. While the case is under way, the court can order interim maintenance for the child.

What changes with the judgment

The judgment declaring paternity gives it all the effects of legal parentage, such as surnames, parental authority (“potestad parental”), maintenance and succession rights. The father becomes obliged to support the child, who will inherit from him like any other child. The date from which that maintenance is owed is another matter.

If the father opposed the claim, the child, or the child's legal representative if the child is a minor, can ask for the legal parentage to be limited to determining that status. In that case the father obtains no civil effect in his favour from it, such as parental authority or rights in the child's estate, but he remains obliged to look after the child and to provide maintenance.

In most of the rest of Spain, the child can also claim paternity at any time during their life. The Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) applies that limitation without any need to ask for it. A father whose paternity is declared despite his opposition is excluded from parental authority and from the rights that the law would give him in the estate of the child, who will only bear his surname if the child or the child's legal representative asks for it. He is still obliged, all the same, to look after the child and to provide maintenance.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.