When can the father's surname be removed?
Only in specific cases, because the father's surname depends on his being legally on record as the father. It does not disappear because the parents separate, because the father does not look after the child or because he has been deprived of parental authority (“patria potestad”). The simplest option is to reverse the order, so that the mother's surname comes first, which is requested by a simple declaration before the “Registro Civil”, the Civil Register. Removing it altogether is possible, among other cases, when paternal parentage ceases to exist, when the mother has been a victim of gender-based violence or in exceptional circumstances. In most of the rest of Spain, where the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) applies, it is also possible when the father was convicted of the acts that led to the child's birth or his paternity was declared in court despite his opposition.
Alburquerque Abogados
Why asking is not enough
The law provides that legal parentage determines a person's surnames. As long as the father is legally on record as such, his surname is one of the child's even if he does not live with the child, does not pay maintenance or has lost parental authority by a court judgment, because losing it does not bring legal parentage to an end.
Changing one surname for another requires a file (“expediente”) to be opened at the Civil Register. One of its requirements is that the two resulting surnames do not come from the same family line. That is why, as a rule, the father's surname cannot be replaced by the mother's second surname, because the child would be left with two surnames from the mother's side.
What can be requested by a simple declaration is to reverse the order. The father's surname does not disappear, but moves to second place. While the child is under sixteen, the reversal is requested on the child's behalf by those who have parental authority. From the age of sixteen the child can request it personally and, on coming of age, or in Catalonia also on becoming emancipated, the law expressly grants the child that right.
The cases in which it is possible
Removing the father's surname is possible in the following cases:
- When paternal parentage ceases to exist, because paternity is successfully challenged or because another person adopts the child, for example the mother's spouse or partner. If paternity is challenged, the child can ask to keep the surnames they had been using, within the two months following the registration of the new legal parentage or, where applicable, following their coming of age.
- When the people concerned are victims of gender-based violence or their descendants who live or have lived with them. The law allows their surnames to be changed without the ordinary requirements.
- When the child habitually uses the surname of the person who is fostering them. That surname can replace the father's if that person, their spouse and their descendants consent.
- When there are reasons of urgency or safety or other exceptional circumstances, which allow the “Ministerio de Justicia”, Spain's Ministry of Justice, to authorise the change by ministerial order.
There is one more case, which depends on the applicable law. If the father was convicted by a final criminal judgment of the acts that led to the child's birth, or his paternity was declared in court despite his opposition, the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, allows the child or their legal representative to ask for legal parentage to be limited to determining who the father is, without any effect in his favour, but it says nothing about surnames. In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code provides that, in those cases, the child does not bear the father's surname unless the child or their legal representative asks for it.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.