When can paternity be challenged?
When the paternity legally on record does not match biological reality, provided that the claim is brought within the time limit and it is proved that the man recorded as the father is not the father. In Catalonia the proof must be conclusive and the time limit is two years, counted differently depending on who brings the challenge, for example from when the husband learns of the birth or from when the evidence is discovered. The paternity of someone who consented to the mother's assisted reproduction treatment cannot be challenged, nor can that of the biological father. In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) generally gives one year to the husband or the child and four years in some cases of paternity outside marriage.
Alburquerque Abogados
Who can bring a challenge and within what time limit
In Catalonia, each person has their own two-year time limit, which is counted as follows:
- The mother's husband, from when he learns of the birth or from when he discovers the evidence on which the challenge is based. If he dies before the time limit expires, his children or descendants and his heirs can bring the action for the time remaining.
- The mother, as regards her husband's paternity, from the birth or from when she discovers the evidence. She can act in her own name or in the interest of the minor child.
- The child, as regards the paternity of their mother's husband, from when they come of age or from when they discover the evidence.
- If the parents are not married, the father, the mother or the child, from when the paternity was established, from when they learned of it or from when new evidence against it came to light. The child can do so within the two years after coming of age or after that evidence comes to light.
Someone who acknowledged a child can also challenge the acknowledgement if it was made as a result of mistake, violence, intimidation or deceit, also within two years. There is no need to try to reach an agreement before suing, because the law exempts parentage proceedings from that requirement.
What must be proved and when a challenge is not possible
In Catalonia, whoever brings the challenge must prove conclusively that the man recorded as the father is not the biological father, which is why a biological test is usually what decides the case.
The challenge does not succeed in the following cases:
- If the paternity results from the mother's assisted reproduction treatment, to which the man recorded as the father consented in the form required by law.
- If the man recorded as the father is the biological father.
- If the paternity was declared by a final judgment.
- If the time limit applicable to the person bringing the challenge has passed.
In most of the rest of Spain
The Spanish Civil Code sets different time limits. The husband has one year from the registration of the parentage in the “Registro Civil”, the Civil Register, but the period does not run while he is unaware of the birth or, if he knew of it, while he does not know that he is not the biological father. The child has one year from the registration or, if they were a minor, from coming of age. If they did not know that they were not the husband's biological child, the year runs from when they find out. If they have not been publicly treated as the husband's child, they can bring a challenge at any time.
For paternity outside marriage, if father and child have publicly treated each other as such, which is what is known as possession of status (“posesión de estado”), it can be challenged by the child, the parent and the forced heirs affected. The right of action expires four years from when, with the parentage already registered, that treatment began. If there has been no possession of status, it can be challenged by anyone it adversely affects.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.