What happens if someone acknowledges a child who is not theirs?

The acknowledgement is valid and the child legally becomes his child for all purposes, even if the man who acknowledged the child knew that he was not the biological father. This is what is known as a “reconocimiento de complacencia”, an acknowledgement made as a favour. The man who made it cannot withdraw it because he changes his mind, but he can challenge paternity in court, by proving that he is not the father, within a time limit which in Catalonia is two years from when paternity was established. Once that period has passed, paternity remains in place as far as he is concerned, although the child keeps their own right of action to challenge it. If the acknowledgement was made in evasion of the law, it is void and its nullity can be sought at any time.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

As long as no one challenges it

Acknowledging a child while knowing that the child is not one's own happens, for example, when the mother's new partner wants the child to have a legal father. The “Registro Civil”, the Civil Register, does not check the biological truth. The “Tribunal Supremo”, Spain's Supreme Court, has held that an acknowledgement is not void because it was made as a favour and that its registration cannot be refused on that ground.

Once effective, it produces all the effects of legal parentage, such as surnames, parental authority (“potestad parental”) while the child is a minor, maintenance and succession rights. If the couple splits up, those effects remain the same as long as the paternity has not been set aside.

Who can challenge it and within what time limit

Catalan law does not prevent someone who acknowledged a child knowing that he was not the father from bringing a challenge. The paternity of a child of unmarried parents can be challenged by the following people within the following time limits:

  • The man who made the acknowledgement, within the two years after his paternity was established. If he believed in good faith that he was the father, the period can be counted from when evidence emerges that he is not.
  • The mother, in her own name and within those same two years. While the child is a minor, she can also challenge it in the child's interest.
  • The child, within the two years after coming of age or after new evidence against the paternity comes to light.

Whoever brings the challenge must prove conclusively that the man recorded as the father is not the father, which is normally done with a biological test. There is no need to try to reach an agreement before suing, because the law exempts parentage proceedings from that requirement.

In most of the rest of Spain, the Supreme Court also allows someone who acknowledged a child as a favour to challenge his paternity. If he did not marry the mother and there has been possession of status (“posesión de estado”), that is, if they have publicly treated each other as father and child, he has four years from when, with the parentage already registered, that treatment began. If he married the mother, the parentage became marital and the time limit is one year, counted from the acknowledgement or from the wedding, if that came later.

The limits

The acknowledgement cannot be revoked. Once the time limit for challenging it has passed, the man who made it remains the father for all purposes, even if he separates from the mother or stops having any relationship with the child. Nor can the paternity of someone who consented, in the form required by law, to the mother's assisted reproduction treatment be set aside.

An acknowledgement made in evasion of the law, that is, to achieve a result that the law prohibits, is a different matter. It is void, the action to have it declared void does not become time-barred and it can be brought by the Public Prosecutor's Office (“Ministerio Fiscal”) or by anyone with a direct and legitimate interest.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.