How is goodwill compensation (“indemnización por clientela”) calculated in an agency agreement?

The law does not provide a formula, but a cap and some criteria. The cap is the average annual amount the agent has been paid by the business over the last five years or, if the contract has lasted less, over the whole time it has lasted. Within that maximum, the amount is set fairly according to the customers the agent has brought in, the advantages the business continues to obtain from them and the commissions the agent loses. The maximum is not granted automatically, so the agent must prove those circumstances.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The statutory cap

The “Ley 12/1992”, Spain's commercial agency act, states that the compensation cannot in any case exceed the average annual amount of the remuneration the agent has received during the last five years. If the contract has lasted less, the annual average over the whole time it has lasted is taken. All amounts the agent has been paid for their activity count, whether fixed or variable.

For example, an agent who in the last five years has been paid 40.000, 45.000, 50.000, 55.000 and 60.000 euros has received 250.000 euros in total. The annual average is 50.000 euros, which is the most that can be received as goodwill compensation. If the contract had lasted only three years, with 30.000, 36.000 and 42.000 euros, the cap would be the average of those three years, 36.000 euros.

How the amount is set

The cap is a maximum, not the compensation. Spanish law derives from a European directive. In interpreting it, the Court of Justice of the European Union has described the calculation in three steps:

  • Calculate the advantages the business will continue to obtain from transactions with the customers the agent brought in or with whom the agent significantly increased sales.
  • Check that this amount is fair, in view of all the circumstances. Of particular weight are any agreement preventing the agent from competing afterwards and the commissions the agent loses, which are those the agent would have earned from those customers had the contract continued.
  • Apply the cap, which operates only if the resulting amount exceeds it.

The person claiming must prove which customers the agent brought in and the sales they generate. The list of customers at the start and at the end of the contract, the trend in sales in the area and the commission statements are all useful. The agent can require the business to show its accounts to the extent necessary to check the commissions.

What falls outside the calculation

A clause that excludes the compensation or fixes it in advance at less than the law provides does not bind the agent, because these rules cannot be changed by contract. Nor is there anything to calculate if the contract ends because of a breach by the agent, if the agent leaves it without a cause the law accepts or if the agent assigns it to another with the business's consent, because in those cases there is no compensation.

The expenses the agent incurred following the business's instructions and has not been able to recoup are claimed separately, as damages, when the business ends an indefinite contract. That item is not subject to the cap.

The claim must be made within one year of the end of the contract. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.