What is goodwill compensation?
It is the goodwill compensation (“indemnización por clientela”) that the law gives a commercial agent when the contract ends, for the customers the agent has won for the business and which the business will continue to benefit from. It is not automatic, because the agent must prove that they brought in new customers or significantly increased transactions with existing ones and that this work will continue to benefit the business. There is a statutory maximum, it must be claimed within one year of the end of the contract and the agent cannot waive it in advance. In some cases the courts recognise similar compensation for a distributor, on more conditions.
Alburquerque Abogados
What it is and when it arises
While the contract lasts, the agent is paid for the transactions the agent promotes. When it ends, the customers the agent has won stay with the business, which can keep selling to them without paying commission any more. Goodwill compensation makes up for that advantage. It is governed by the “Ley 12/1992” on the agency contract, Spain's commercial agency act, which recognises it whether the contract was for a fixed term or indefinite.
To be entitled to it, these conditions must be met:
- The agent has brought in new customers or has significantly increased transactions with those the business already had.
- The agent's previous activity can continue to give the business substantial advantages.
- It is fair to grant it, given the commissions the agent loses, any agreements preventing the agent from competing afterwards or the other circumstances of the case.
If the contract ends because the agent dies, the agent's heirs can claim it.
When there is no entitlement
The law excludes it in three cases:
- When the business ends the contract because the agent has breached their obligations.
- When it is the agent who ends it, unless the agent does so for reasons attributable to the business or because of age, disability or illness, if the agent cannot reasonably be required to continue.
- When the agent, with the business's consent, assigns the contract to another person.
What you should know
The rules on agency are mandatory, so a clause by which the agent waives this compensation in advance is not valid. The law sets a maximum, which depends on what the agent has been paid in recent years. Within it, the amount depends on what is proved. How it is calculated is a separate matter. The time limit for claiming it is one year from the end of the contract. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing. Within Spain, lawsuits on the agency contract are for the courts of the agent's domicile.
It is different from the damages the agent can claim when the business ends an indefinite contract without giving the agent time to recoup the expenses incurred following its instructions. The two can be added together.
The distribution agreement, in which the distributor buys and resells on its own account, has no law of its own. In some cases the courts allow similar compensation, applying the agent's rule by analogy, when the distributor proves that it created the customer base and that the supplier will continue to benefit from it. They do not do so automatically and generally respect what the contract says.
The same name is given to the compensation that the “Ley de Arrendamientos Urbanos” (LAU), Spain's urban tenancies act, gives in some cases to the tenant of commercial premises when the lease ends. That is a separate matter, with requirements of its own.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.