Is there goodwill compensation in a distribution agreement?

The law does not provide for it, because the distribution agreement has no regulation of its own, but in some cases the courts award it by applying the rule on agency agreements by analogy. It is not automatic. What counts first is the contract, which may regulate it or exclude it. If it does not exclude it, the distributor has to prove that it created or significantly increased the customer base and that the supplier will continue to benefit from it. When it is awarded, the courts take as a maximum the annual average of the distributor's net profits over the last five years.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Why it is disputed

A commercial agent is entitled by law to goodwill compensation (“indemnización por clientela”) when the agency agreement ends and certain requirements are met. A distributor, who buys and resells on its own account, has no equivalent rule. The courts have accepted that the agent's rule can be applied to a distributor by analogy, that is, as a similar case that the law does not regulate, where its situation resembles the agent's, for example because it is part of the supplier's commercial network and works under the supplier's brand and following its guidelines. The rule is not applied automatically and has to be justified in each case.

What must be present

For a distributor to obtain it, the following conditions are usually required:

  • That the contract has not excluded it. Unlike the position with agency, in distribution the courts generally accept a clause that rules out this compensation or replaces it with another system of settlement.
  • That the distributor has created customers or significantly increased the existing customer base, through its own efforts.
  • That the supplier can go on benefiting from that customer base afterwards. This is not usually the case where customers buy for the prestige of the brand and not because of the distributor's work, or where they leave with the distributor.
  • That the contract does not end because of a breach by the distributor or because the distributor decides to leave it for no reason attributable to the supplier.

The burden of proof lies on the distributor. Useful evidence includes the customer list at the start and at the end, the trend in sales and the details of the customers whom the supplier has continued to serve.

How much and what else can be claimed

The reference point is the agency cap, adapted. What is taken is not the distributor's turnover or its gross margin, which is the difference between the purchase price and the resale price. What is taken is its net profit, after deducting expenses and taxes. The annual average of that profit over the last five years, or over the life of the contract if it was shorter, works as a maximum. Within that limit, the amount depends on what is proved.

Compensation for the customer base is different from other claims that may accompany the end of the contract, such as damages for termination without proper notice, investments that could not be written off or stock left in the warehouse. Each has its own rules.

The law sets no time limit of its own for claiming it. For agency the period is one year from the end of the contract, so the prudent course is to claim in writing within that year. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.