Is guardianship the same as parental authority (“patria potestad”)?
No. Parental authority (“patria potestad”, which in Catalonia is called “potestad parental”) belongs to parents by virtue of being parents, without anyone having to grant it to them. Guardianship is a protective institution that the court sets up when a minor is not under the parental authority of either parent, for example because both have died or have been deprived of it. The guardian looks after, brings up and represents the minor and manages the minor's property, just as parents do, but under closer court supervision. Moreover, guardianship does not create legal parentage, so the guardian does not become the minor's father or mother.
Alburquerque Abogados
What they have in common
Both exist so that the minor has someone to look after them, bring them up, represent them and manage their property. Both are exercised in the interests of the minor, who has the right to be heard according to their age and maturity. And both end when the minor turns eighteen or becomes emancipated.
That is why ordinary guardianship is not set up while either parent has parental authority. If one of them dies, the other exercises it alone and there is no need to appoint a guardian.
How they differ
The main differences are as follows:
- Origin. Parental authority arises from legal parentage, so parents have it from the moment they become parents. The guardian, by contrast, acts because the court has appointed them, usually the person the parents named in their will or in a public deed or, if no one was named, the relative preferred by law.
- Supervision. Parents need the court's authorisation for some important acts, such as selling a property belonging to their child, but in general they do not have to draw up an inventory or submit periodic accounts. In Catalonia they can even replace that authorisation with the consent of the child, if the child is at least sixteen, or that of the child's two closest relatives, given in a public deed. The guardian cannot use that alternative. The guardian needs the court's authorisation, must draw up an inventory of the minor's property at the outset and must account for how the property is managed, generally every year.
- Excuses. Parental authority is a function from which parents cannot be excused. Someone appointed guardian, on the other hand, can be excused if they have a reason, such as age or illness.
- Remuneration. Parents are not paid for exercising parental authority. Guardianship is in principle unpaid, but remuneration can be set for the guardian if the minor's assets allow it.
- Family ties. Guardianship does not change legal parentage. The minor keeps their surnames and their ties with their family, including their rights in their parents' estates. The guardian does not become their father or mother.
When the child is under the guardianship of the public authorities
There is one situation in which guardianship and the parents' authority overlap in time. When the public authorities make a declaration of abandonment (“desamparo”) in respect of a minor, which in Catalonia is a matter for the Generalitat de Catalunya (the Catalan government), they assume the minor's guardianship by operation of law. The parents' authority is not lost but is suspended while that situation lasts. If the declaration of abandonment is set aside, the parents resume exercising it.
Deprivation of parental authority, by contrast, is ordered by a court and means that the father or mother ceases to hold it. If neither of them retains it, a guardian is appointed.
Since 2021, a guardian is no longer appointed for an adult who needs support to exercise their legal capacity, nor is parental authority extended when the child turns eighteen. What happens to guardians appointed before the reform and the support measures for adults are separate matters.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.