What are the grounds for refusing grandparents visiting rights?
The law does not provide a list. In Catalonia, the “Código Civil de Cataluña”, the Catalan Civil Code, only allows parents to prevent their children's relationship with their grandparents if there is just cause. It also allows the court to refuse, suspend or change the form of that relationship if the grandparents fail to fulfil their duties or if the relationship may harm the children. In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code (“Código civil”) also requires just cause. The courts assess it case by case and always from the standpoint of the child's best interests, so a poor relationship between the parents and the grandparents is not enough on its own.
Alburquerque Abogados
What the courts regard as just cause
Just cause is not defined in the law. According to the “Tribunal Supremo”, Spain's Supreme Court, it must be examined in each case and must relate to the interests of the child, not those of the adults. Since the rule is that the relationship should continue, it is for the person objecting to prove the cause.
What usually leads to visits being refused or limited is that the relationship puts the child at risk. That is the case with ill-treatment or abuse, an addiction that affects the child's care or behaviour that damages the child's stability, such as speaking ill of the parents in front of the child, constantly undermining their authority or making the child take sides in the adults' conflict.
Another situation is where the grandparents become a channel for the child to see a parent whose visits the court has restricted or suspended. In Catalonia, that risk is a form of harm to the child that the court can take into account. In most of the rest of Spain, the Spanish Civil Code expressly requires the court to prevent the relationship with the grandparents from being used to get round those decisions.
What is not enough
A poor relationship between the parents and the grandparents is not, on its own, just cause. The Supreme Court has rejected the idea that the father's conflict with the deceased mother's family allows the children to be kept away from their grandparents. It has also corrected a court that had looked to the father's interests rather than the children's. The conflict only counts when it is so intense that contact ends up harming the minor.
Nor is hypothetical harm enough, such as a fear, unsupported by any facts, that the grandparents will influence the children. In a case in which there had been a serious accusation against the grandmother that was never proved, the Supreme Court upheld short visits at a child contact centre (“punto de encuentro familiar”), with monitoring of how the relationship was developing.
The child's opinion carries more weight the more mature the child is. The court hears the child and weighs what they say together with all the other circumstances.
Refusing, limiting or suspending visits
Where there is a cause, the court does not have to cut off the relationship completely. It can reduce the visits, have them take place at a contact centre with professionals supervising them or suspend them for a time. It only refuses them altogether when any contact would harm the child.
Whatever it decides can be reviewed if circumstances change, for example if the reason why the visits were limited no longer exists.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.