What is the corporate liability action against a company director?
It is the claim by which a company requires its director to make good the harm caused to the company's own assets by conduct contrary to the law, the articles of association or the duties of the office. The general meeting decides on it by ordinary majority and the resolution entails the removal of the director concerned. If the company does not claim, shareholders holding at least 5 % of the capital may do so in its place and, as a last resort, the creditors. What is recovered goes to the company, not to the person who sues. The limitation period is four years from the day on which the action could first be brought.
Alburquerque Abogados
What is claimed
Directors are liable to the company for any harm they cause it by acts or omissions contrary to the law or the articles of association, or by breaching the duties of their office, provided there is wilful misconduct or fault. Where the act is contrary to the law or the articles of association, fault is presumed. Typical examples are taking money from the company to which the director is not entitled, selling company assets below their value to people close to the director, or diverting business to another company of theirs.
The fact that the general meeting authorised or ratified the act does not release the director. Where there are several, all those who adopted the resolution or carried out the act are jointly and severally liable. A director is released only by proving that they took no part in the act and, in addition, that they did not know of it, did all they could to prevent the harm or expressly opposed it.
The compensation goes into the company's assets, not the shareholders'. If the director has directly harmed the assets of a shareholder or a third party, the route is a different one, the individual liability action (“acción individual”).
Who can bring it
The law sets an order of priority among those who may sue:
- The company, following a resolution of the general meeting. Any shareholder may ask for the matter to be put to a vote even if it is not on the agenda. An ordinary majority is enough, since the articles of association cannot require a different one. The resolution entails the removal of the directors concerned.
- Shareholders holding, alone or together, at least 5 % of the capital, which is the percentage needed to request that a general meeting be called. They may sue in the company's interest if the directors do not call the meeting requested to deal with the matter, if the meeting votes against, or if the company does not file the claim within the month following the resolution. If the claim is based on a breach of the duty of loyalty, they may sue directly, without going through the general meeting.
- The company's creditors, if neither the company nor the shareholders have sued and the company's assets are not enough to pay their claims.
The minority route is the usual one when the director is also the majority shareholder and the general meeting refuses to claim against them. If the claim succeeds in whole or in part, the company must reimburse the shareholder's necessary expenses, within the limits set by the law.
Limitation period, waiver and abuse
The limitation period for the action is four years from the day on which it could first be brought. Approving the annual accounts does not prevent the action from being brought and does not amount to a waiver of it. The general meeting may waive the action or settle with the director at any time, unless shareholders representing 5 % of the capital object.
The corporate liability action (“acción social”) exists to repair real harm to the company. When the majority imposes a resolution in its own interest, without any reasonable need on the part of the company and to the unjustified detriment of the other shareholders, the resolution may be challenged as an abuse of majority. The courts have applied that principle to resolutions that use the corporate liability action as a mere tool for some other purpose.
The claim is filed with the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”). The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before suing.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.