What is the liability of directors in insolvency proceedings?

A company going into insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) does not make its directors liable for the company's debts. The liability specific to insolvency proceedings arises when the judge classifies the insolvency as culpable and declares them persons affected by the classification. In that case they are disqualified, lose their claims against the company and may be ordered to return what they obtained improperly and to compensate for the damage. If the liquidation stage has been opened, the judge can also order them to pay with their own assets all or part of what the creditors do not recover, to the extent that their conduct generated or aggravated the insolvency. If the insolvency is fortuitous there is no such liability, although other routes for claiming against them, such as the one for not having dissolved the company in time, follow their own rules.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The rule and culpable insolvency

The debts of a limited company (“sociedad limitada”) or a public limited company (“sociedad anónima”) are paid by the company out of its own assets. Insolvency proceedings do not change that rule. What they add is a liability that depends on how the insolvency is classified. If the insolvency is fortuitous, the directors bear no such liability.

If it is culpable, the judgment disqualifies the directors affected for a period of two to fifteen years, deprives them of any claims they had against the company and may order them to return what they obtained improperly and to compensate for the damage. On top of that there may be an order to cover the shortfall (“condena a cubrir el déficit”), which is the one that can hit their personal assets hardest. The details of the other consequences are another matter.

The order to cover the shortfall

The shortfall is the difference between the value of the assets shown in the insolvency practitioner's inventory and the total of the claims recognised in the list of creditors. Broadly speaking, it is what is lacking to pay everyone.

The judge can order the directors to cover it, in whole or in part, if these conditions are met:

  • That the insolvency has been classified as culpable and the director has been declared a person affected by the classification. Those who can be declared affected are the directors and liquidators, whether formally appointed or de facto, the general managers and anyone who held those posts in the two years before the insolvency order.
  • That the classification takes place once the liquidation stage has been opened, that is, when the assets are going to be sold to pay the creditors.
  • That the conduct that made the insolvency culpable generated or aggravated the insolvency. The order is adjusted to that extent, so it need not cover the whole shortfall.

If several people are ordered to pay, the judgment must specify the amount corresponding to each according to their part in the events. To secure payment, the judge can, from the insolvency order onwards, attach as an interim measure assets belonging to the directors, liquidators and general managers, including those who held those posts in the previous two years, where there are reasonable grounds to believe that they may end up being ordered to cover the shortfall.

The other routes for claiming against them

Insolvency proceedings also change who can bring claims against the directors by other routes and when.

The corporate liability action (“acción social”), by which the company claims from the director the harm the director caused it, can be brought only by the insolvency practitioner from the insolvency order onwards. It is decided by the insolvency judge.

Liability for not having taken steps to dissolve the company when the law required it allows creditors to claim from the directors the debts arising after the ground for dissolution. During the insolvency proceedings it is put on hold. From the insolvency order until the composition with creditors (“convenio”) takes effect or, if there is none, until the proceedings end, no new claims are admitted by that route and those already under way are stayed. Its requirements are another matter.

A creditor's claim for harm the director caused them directly, debts to the tax authorities and Social Security that are claimed from the director and any guarantees the director has signed personally have their own rules, which are also another matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.