What is a restructuring plan?
It is an agreement between a company in difficulty and its creditors, governed by the consolidated Insolvency Act (“texto refundido de la Ley Concursal”), to change its debts or its organisation and avoid insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”). It can defer or reduce debts, convert them into capital, sell assets or parts of the business or change the way the company operates. The affected creditors vote on it grouped in classes and, if the judge approves it, which is called court confirmation (“homologación”), it also binds those who did not vote in favour. Unlike in insolvency proceedings, the company continues to run its business and no insolvency practitioner is appointed.
Alburquerque Abogados
What it is for and who can use it
Under the law, a restructuring plan is one that changes the composition, terms or structure of the debtor's assets, liabilities or equity, that is, of what it owns, what it owes or its capital and reserves. It can include the sale of assets, of business units or of the whole business as a going concern and any change needed in the way it operates. In practice it is used to extend repayment periods, reduce interest, agree a grace period, which is a period during which no principal is repaid, or a write-down (“quita”), which is the forgiveness of part of the debt. It can also be used to convert debt into shares or quotas (“participaciones”) in the company itself.
It can be used by individuals and companies carrying on a business or professional activity. Micro-enterprises, which are those with fewer than ten employees and an annual turnover of less than 700.000 euros or liabilities of less than 350.000 euros, are excluded because they have their own special procedure. So are certain entities, such as banks, insurers and public bodies.
The law allows it to be used in three situations:
- Likelihood of insolvency, when it is objectively foreseeable that, without a plan, the debtor will not be able to pay regularly the debts falling due over the next two years.
- Imminent insolvency, when it foresees that it will not be able to pay them regularly within the next three months.
- Actual insolvency, when it can no longer pay regularly the debts falling due, provided that no petition for insolvency proceedings filed by a creditor has been admitted for processing.
The plan can be negotiated after notifying the court of the opening of negotiations with the creditors, which is known as the pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”), or without that notice.
Which debts it can change
The plan can change the maturity, amount, interest or security of almost any debt, including debts that depend on a condition. The law excludes these:
- Maintenance arising from a family relationship, kinship or marriage.
- Compensation for non-contractual liability, which is liability arising from damage caused outside a contract.
- Debts arising from employment relationships, except those of senior management staff.
Debts owed to the tax authorities and to Social Security can only be included subject to strict requirements and can never be reduced. The plan can only defer them and, in general, they must be paid off within the twelve months following court confirmation.
How it differs from insolvency proceedings
In insolvency proceedings, the judge appoints an insolvency practitioner who supervises or replaces the company's directors. In a restructuring plan there is no insolvency practitioner and the company keeps the management of its business. If a restructuring expert is appointed, the expert's role is to help with the negotiations and prepare the reports required by law.
The negotiations are private and the plan is formalised before a notary. The judge intervenes above all to confirm it, when it is intended to bind creditors or shareholders who have not voted in favour. The decision confirming it is published in the “Registro Público Concursal”, the public insolvency register. The aim is for the company to remain viable without ending up in insolvency proceedings.
How it differs from a refinancing with the bank and which is advisable in each case is a separate matter.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.