What is court confirmation (“homologación”) of a restructuring plan?

It is the judge's approval of the plan, which makes it binding even on the creditors and shareholders who did not vote in favour of it. Without court confirmation, the plan binds only those who sign it. It is applied for by the debtor or by any affected creditor who has signed the plan, with a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”), to the judge of the commercial section of the first-instance court (“tribunal de instancia”). The law gives the judge fifteen days to decide from the publication of the admission of the application. Creditors who did not vote in favour can then challenge the court confirmation before the “Audiencia Provincial”, the provincial appeal court.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

When it is needed

Court confirmation is necessary when the plan seeks to achieve any of the following:

  • Extending its effects to creditors or classes of creditors that have not voted in favour of it, or to the shareholders of the debtor company.
  • Terminating contracts of the company because this is in the interests of the restructuring.
  • Protecting the financing that the company receives during the negotiations or that the plan provides for, so that it cannot be rescinded in subsequent insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) and is paid with priority in them.

How the application is handled

In a company, the decision to apply for court confirmation lies with the management body. The application is accompanied by a copy of the notarial document recording the plan with the certificate of the majorities and, if there is one, the restructuring expert's report. The decision lies with the judge of the commercial section of the first-instance court that would have jurisdiction over the company's insolvency proceedings or, if the opening of negotiations had been notified, with the judge of the court that received that notice.

On admitting the application, the judge prohibits the commencement of enforcement proceedings against the debtor's assets and stays any already under way until a decision is reached. The admission is published in the public insolvency register (“Registro Público Concursal”) and the judge rules by order within the following fifteen days. The judge confirms the plan unless it is manifestly clear from the documents that it does not meet the legal requirements. The main ones are these:

  • That the plan offers a reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvency proceedings and of ensuring the viability of the business in the short and medium term.
  • That it has been approved by all the classes and, where the law so requires, by the debtor or the shareholders. If a class voted against, the law allows the plan to be imposed on it in some cases, which requires a restructuring expert.
  • That claims in the same class receive the same treatment.
  • That the plan has been notified to all the affected creditors.

The applicant can ask for those affected to be given an opportunity to object before confirmation. They then have fifteen days and the judge gives judgment within a month, with no appeal.

What effects it has and how it is challenged

Once the plan has been confirmed, its effects extend immediately to all the affected claims, to the debtor and to the shareholders, even if the order is not final. Creditors who did not vote in favour keep their rights against the guarantors and other parties securing their claim. For those who voted in favour, it depends on what was agreed with the guarantor and, if nothing was agreed, on the rules governing the guarantee.

Affected creditors who did not vote in favour can challenge the order before the provincial appeal court within fifteen days of its publication in the public insolvency register. They can argue, among other grounds, that the classes or the majorities are not correct, that their claim is reduced by manifestly more than is necessary for the business to be viable or that they come off worse under the plan than in a liquidation in insolvency proceedings. Creditors in a class that voted against have grounds of their own, such as receiving worse treatment than another class of the same rank.

The challenge does not suspend the plan and no appeal lies against the judgment. If it is upheld, the plan ceases to apply to the creditor who brought the challenge, who is entitled to compensation from the debtor if the effects can no longer be reversed. If the ground is that the majorities were lacking or that the classes were wrongly formed, the entire plan ceases to have effect.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.