What is the difference between insolvency proceedings (“concurso”) and the pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”)?
The pre-insolvency stage is a period of protection for the company to negotiate a restructuring plan with its creditors without losing control of its business. Insolvency proceedings are court proceedings that bring all the creditors together in order to pay them through a composition with creditors (“convenio”) or through the sale of the assets, with the involvement of an insolvency practitioner. The pre-insolvency stage is available even when insolvency is only likely, whereas insolvency proceedings require it to be imminent or actual. In addition, the pre-insolvency stage can be kept confidential and insolvency proceedings are always made public.
Alburquerque Abogados
What each one is for
The pre-insolvency stage, whose legal name is notice of the opening of negotiations with creditors, is a voluntary step. The company notifies the court that it is negotiating with its creditors and obtains a few months' protection against much of the enforcement so that it can reach an agreement with them, which the law calls a restructuring plan. If it does not succeed, the protection ends and, if it can no longer pay its debts regularly, it will have to petition for insolvency proceedings.
Insolvency proceedings are collective court proceedings. All the creditors are bound by them and can only be paid in accordance with their rules. They seek to pay the creditors through a composition, which is a payment agreement accepted by the creditors and approved by the judge, or through liquidation, which is the sale of the company's assets to distribute the proceeds.
The differences in practice
The main differences are these:
- When it can be sought. The pre-insolvency stage is already available where there is a likelihood of insolvency, when it is foreseeable that the company will not be able to pay regularly the debts falling due over the next two years. It is also available in imminent or actual insolvency. Insolvency proceedings are only available when the company foresees that it will not be able to pay within the next three months or when it can no longer do so.
- Who decides. In the pre-insolvency stage the directors keep all their powers. In insolvency proceedings the judge normally appoints an insolvency practitioner. The judge does not appoint one at the outset if the company has no assets with which to pay even the costs of the proceedings, which is known as insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”). As a general rule, if the company itself petitioned for insolvency proceedings, its directors remain in charge but need the insolvency practitioner's authorisation, whereas if a creditor petitioned, the insolvency practitioner replaces them.
- Enforcement. The pre-insolvency stage protects, in principle, only the assets needed for the business, for a limited time and with almost no effect against the tax authorities and Social Security. Insolvency proceedings prevent, with some exceptions, attachments and enforcement against the company's assets from being started or continued, including those of the tax authorities and Social Security.
- Publication. The notice of the pre-insolvency stage is published in the “Registro Público Concursal”, the public insolvency register, unless the company asks for it to be kept confidential. The insolvency order (the court's declaration opening the proceedings) is always published in the “Boletín Oficial del Estado” (Spain's Official State Gazette) and in that same register. If the business is a company, the order is also recorded in the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”).
How they relate to each other
The pre-insolvency stage is not compulsory. It can serve to avoid insolvency proceedings or be the step that precedes them. If the company is in actual insolvency and the negotiations fail, it must petition for insolvency proceedings within a month of the end of the protection, which lasts three months and can only be extended to a limited extent.
Micro-enterprises cannot use this pre-insolvency stage or petition for insolvency proceedings. The law provides a special procedure for them with its own rules, which also includes its own notice of negotiations with creditors.
This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.