Which is better, refinancing or restructuring a company's debt?

It depends on how many creditors need to be won over and on how much the debt needs to change. Refinancing usually means agreeing new money or more time with the bank, which is quick and discreet, but the agreement binds only those who sign it. For restructuring, which means changing the terms of the debt, the Spanish Insolvency Act (“Ley Concursal”) also offers the restructuring plan, which allows write-downs, deferrals or the conversion of debt into equity to be imposed on creditors who do not agree, with more requirements and with the involvement of a judge. If the problem lies with one or two banks willing to negotiate, refinancing is usually enough. If there are many creditors or one of them objects, the plan is usually more useful.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

What each one is

Refinancing means obtaining new financing, from the same bank or from another, to pay the debt that is falling due or to replace it with other debt with more time to pay or on better terms. Restructuring means changing the terms of the debt that already exists, for example with more time to pay, with a grace period, which is a period without repaying principal, with a write-down, which is the forgiveness of part of the debt, or by converting debt into quotas (“participaciones”) in the company.

Both can be agreed directly with each creditor, who is free to accept or not. That agreement binds only that creditor. The Insolvency Act adds the restructuring plan, which can include new financing and change almost all the debts, including those owed to suppliers. Once confirmed by the court, it also binds the creditors who did not vote in favour of it.

When each one is suitable

A refinancing agreed with the bank is usually enough in these cases:

  • The debt that is causing concern is held by a few lenders, who are willing to negotiate.
  • The problem is one of liquidity rather than excessive debt, so it can be solved with more time or with new money.
  • The aim is to avoid the publicity that court confirmation of a plan entails.

The restructuring plan is more useful in these other cases:

  • There are many creditors, including suppliers, or one of them refuses to negotiate and can block the solution.
  • It is necessary to reduce the debt, convert part of it into equity, sell part of the business or terminate contracts that are weighing the company down.

Neither route allows debts to the tax authorities or to Social Security to be reduced. The plan can only defer them, within strict limits. Applying to them for a deferral through administrative channels is a separate matter.

What to weigh up before choosing

In a refinancing, the bank usually asks for new security, such as a mortgage over a property belonging to the company or a personal guarantee from the shareholders or the director. Whoever gives a guarantee is liable with their own assets if the company does not pay, so it is advisable to weigh up that risk before signing.

In addition, if the company later goes into insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”), acts carried out in the two years before the petition that are detrimental to the other creditors can be rescinded, that is, set aside. The law presumes that detriment, unless the contrary is proved, in the case of security in rem given to secure debts that already existed or the new debts that replace them, as often happens in a refinancing. A court-confirmed plan protects the new financing and the acts needed to implement it against rescission, if the claims affected represent at least 51 % of all the company's debts.

In return, the plan requires reaching the majorities, formalising it before a notary and, to impose it on those who do not accept it, applying for court confirmation with a lawyer and a court agent (“procurador”). Micro-enterprises, which are those with fewer than ten employees and an annual turnover below 700.000 euros or liabilities below 350.000 euros, cannot use it and have their own special procedure.

If the company can no longer pay its debts regularly, its directors have a duty to petition for insolvency proceedings within two months of the date on which they knew or should have known of that situation, so it is unwise to drag out an informal negotiation. The breathing space gained by notifying the court that negotiations with the creditors are under way, the so-called pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”), is a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.