What happens if the restructuring plan is breached?

Once the plan has been confirmed by the court, creditors cannot ask for it to be terminated for breach or have their original claims reinstated, unless the plan itself provides for this. They can, however, claim what the plan grants them and has not been paid to them. Public creditors, such as the tax authorities and Social Security, can always ask for the plan to be terminated as regards their claims if the instalments are not paid to them or if the company stops paying its current taxes or social security contributions. If the breach is due to the company being insolvent, any creditor can petition for insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) and the directors are obliged to do so.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The plan still stands

If the company stops paying what was agreed, the creditors cannot ask for the plan to be terminated, that is, set aside. Nor can they ask for the write-downs, deferrals and other changes that the plan made to their claims to disappear. The exception is where the plan itself says otherwise, for example that, if it is not complied with, the claims revert to their original terms. That is why it is advisable for the plan to provide from the outset for what happens if it is not complied with.

What each creditor can do is claim the amounts that the plan grants them and that have fallen due without being paid. The law generally requires an attempt to reach an agreement before bringing a claim. If the debt had guarantors, a creditor who did not vote in favour of the plan keeps their rights against them. For one who voted in favour, it depends on what was agreed with the guarantor and, if nothing was agreed, on the rules governing the guarantee.

If it is the company that foresees that it will be unable to comply, it is advisable for it to raise this with its creditors as soon as possible. Court confirmation of another plan cannot be sought until a year has passed since confirmation of the previous one was applied for.

Debts to the tax authorities and to Social Security

Public creditors are the exception. If the plan affected their claims, they can in any event ask for it to be terminated as regards those claims when it is breached. The law considers the plan to have been breached in two cases:

  • If the company fails to pay any of the instalments into which the plan deferred those debts.
  • If, while the plan is in force, the company runs up new debts for the taxes or contributions of each period.

The plan cannot reduce those debts and, as a general rule, they must be paid off within twelve months of court confirmation.

If the cause is insolvency

If the company fails to comply because it cannot pay its debts regularly, any of its creditors can petition for insolvency proceedings against it. The company itself is obliged to petition within two months of the date on which it knew or should have known of that situation. If it does not, its directors may be held liable, which is a separate matter.

In those insolvency proceedings, the changes that the plan made to the claims are maintained, unless the plan says otherwise, so each creditor's claim is the amount that the plan granted them and that they have not received. In addition, if the claims affected by the plan represented at least 51 % of all the company's debts, neither the financing received during the negotiations or to implement the plan nor the acts needed to carry it out can be rescinded, unless it is proved that they were done in fraud of the creditors.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.