Who can propose a restructuring plan?

It can be proposed both by the company or business owner in difficulty and by their creditors. Asking the judge to approve it, which is known as court confirmation (“homologación”), is a matter for the debtor or for any affected creditor who has signed it, although in many cases a plan put forward by the creditors also needs the approval of the debtor or of its shareholders. Private individuals with no business activity cannot use it, nor can micro-enterprises, which have their own special procedure. The restructuring expert, if one is appointed, helps to negotiate and draft the plan but is not the one who submits it to the judge.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The debtor

Any person or company carrying on a business or professional activity and having difficulty in paying can propose a plan. It is enough that it is objectively foreseeable that they will be unable to pay regularly the debts falling due over the next two years. They can also do so if they can no longer pay them, as long as no petition for insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) filed by a creditor has been admitted for processing.

In a company, the decision to apply for court confirmation lies with the management body. The plan can be negotiated after notifying the court of the opening of negotiations with the creditors, which is known as the pre-insolvency stage (“preconcurso”), or without such notice.

The law excludes these debtors:

  • Private individuals who do not carry on a business or professional activity, who can turn to insolvency proceedings.
  • Micro-enterprises, which are those with fewer than ten employees and an annual turnover below 700.000 euros or liabilities below 350.000 euros. They have their own special procedure.
  • Banks, insurers, investment firms and other financial institutions, as well as public authorities and public bodies.

The creditors

Creditors can also negotiate a plan and submit it, because any affected creditor who has signed it can ask the judge to confirm it. The law does, however, protect the debtor and its shareholders in these cases:

  • If the debtor is an individual, the plan needs their approval.
  • If it is a business with no more than forty-nine employees and an annual turnover or balance sheet of no more than ten million euros, court confirmation can be sought only if the debtor and, where applicable, its shareholders have approved the plan. This rule does not apply to companies belonging to a group required to consolidate its accounts.
  • In other companies, if the plan requires resolutions of the general meeting, such as a capital increase or the conversion of debt into quotas (“participaciones”), the shareholders' general meeting must approve it. That approval can be dispensed with only if the company is in actual or imminent insolvency.

Shareholders, as such, cannot apply for court confirmation, even though in the cases just described they have to approve the plan.

The restructuring expert

This is an independent professional appointed by the judge at the request of the debtor or of creditors representing more than half of the debts that may be affected. If the creditors request the appointment, they pay the expert's fees, unless the court-confirmed plan makes the debtor bear them. The appointment is compulsory when the plan is to be imposed on a class of creditors or on shareholders who have not voted in favour of it.

The expert's role is to assist the debtor and the creditors in negotiating and drafting the plan and to prepare the reports required by law or by the judge, independently and impartially. The law does not give the expert the power to apply for court confirmation, which can be sought only by the debtor or by the creditors who have signed the plan.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.