How is a restructuring plan approved?

It is approved by the creditors whose claims are changed by the plan, who vote grouped in classes. A class approves it when creditors holding more than two thirds of the amount of its claims vote in favour, or three quarters if they are claims with security in rem, such as a mortgage. In general, if the plan requires resolutions of the general meeting, such as a capital increase, the shareholders must also approve it by an ordinary majority. In some cases the approval of the debtor itself is also required. It is then formalised before a notary and, for it to bind those who did not vote in favour, the court has to confirm it.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Who votes and how the classes are formed

The proposed plan must be notified individually, by post or by e-mail, to all the creditors whose claims may be affected. All the affected creditors vote. If a debt is guaranteed by a third party, the creditor votes, not the guarantor.

The creditors do not all vote together but in classes, each bringing together those with a common interest according to objective criteria. The main rules are as follows:

  • In principle, claims that would have the same rank in insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”), that is, the same place in the order of payment, share a common interest.
  • Claims of the same rank can be separated into different classes when there are sufficient reasons, for example so as not to mix banks with suppliers or depending on how the plan affects each one.
  • Creditors that are small or medium-sized enterprises and on which the plan imposes a sacrifice of more than 50 % of their claim must form a separate class.
  • Claims with security in rem form a single class, unless the assets charged are so different that separating them is justified.
  • Debts to the tax authorities and to Social Security form a separate class within their rank.

The majorities

Each class votes separately and what counts is the amount of the claims, not the number of creditors. A class approves the plan when creditors holding more than two thirds of the total amount of that class's claims vote in favour. If the class is made up of claims with security in rem, three quarters are needed. In a class of suppliers whose claims total 900.000 euros, the plan is approved if suppliers with claims of more than 600.000 euros vote in favour. As the majority is calculated on the total for the class, a creditor who does not vote counts the same as one who votes against.

The approved plan is formalised before a notary, with a certificate from the restructuring expert or, if none has been appointed, from an auditor, confirming that the majorities have been reached.

If a class votes against, the plan can still be imposed in some cases, but that depends on court confirmation, which is a separate matter.

Approval by the shareholders and by the debtor

If the plan includes measures that need a resolution of the general meeting, such as a capital increase or the conversion of debt into quotas (“participaciones”), the shareholders vote on it under these special rules:

  • A period of ten days between the notice of the meeting and the meeting itself is enough.
  • The agenda is confined to approving or rejecting the plan as a whole, with no other business.
  • The ordinary quorum and majority laid down by law are sufficient, even if the articles of association require higher majorities.
  • The resolution can be challenged only by the same route and within the same time limit as the court confirmation.

If the company is in actual or imminent insolvency, the plan can be confirmed even if the shareholders do not approve it, except in businesses with no more than forty-nine employees and an annual turnover or balance sheet of no more than ten million euros that are not part of a group required to consolidate its accounts. In those businesses the approval of the debtor and, where applicable, of its shareholders is always required. If the debtor is an individual, the plan also needs their approval.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.