What are voluntary insolvency proceedings (“concurso voluntario”)?

They are insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) that the debtor itself petitions for, whether a company or a private individual, before a creditor does so. If the first petition to reach the court is a creditor's, the proceedings are creditor-initiated (“concurso necesario”). Voluntary does not mean optional, because anyone who can no longer pay their debts regularly is obliged to petition within two months of the date on which they knew or should have known of it. The most noticeable difference is who manages the debtor's assets afterwards. As a general rule, in voluntary proceedings the debtor continues to do so, under the supervision of an insolvency practitioner, whereas in creditor-initiated proceedings the insolvency practitioner takes the debtor's place.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

When proceedings are voluntary and when they are creditor-initiated

The Spanish Insolvency Act (“Ley Concursal”) follows a simple criterion, namely who filed the first petition. If it was the debtor, the proceedings are voluntary. If it was a creditor or another person entitled to petition, they are creditor-initiated, even if the debtor later files a petition too.

There is one exception. The proceedings are also creditor-initiated if, in the three months before the debtor's petition, another person had filed theirs and it had been admitted for processing, even if that person later withdrew it, did not attend the hearing or did not confirm it at the hearing.

The debtor can petition for its own insolvency proceedings when it can no longer meet its obligations regularly, which is what the law calls actual insolvency. It can also do so earlier, when it foresees that it will be unable to meet them in the following three months, which is imminent insolvency. In the first case it has a duty to petition within two months. In the second it is an option.

Micro-enterprises, which are generally those with fewer than ten employees and an annual turnover below 700.000 euros or debts below 350.000 euros, do not go into insolvency proceedings but use a special procedure, which is a separate matter.

What changes depending on who files the petition

The judge states in the insolvency order itself whether the proceedings are voluntary or creditor-initiated. The difference has these consequences:

  • Management of the assets. In voluntary proceedings, the debtor continues to manage and dispose of its assets, but its decisions require the authorisation of the insolvency practitioner. In creditor-initiated proceedings, those powers are suspended and the insolvency practitioner exercises them instead. The judge can order otherwise in a particular case if the reasons are given.
  • The position of the creditor who filed the petition. In creditor-initiated proceedings, the costs of that creditor's petition are paid out of the debtor's assets as expenses of the proceedings themselves. In addition, the creditor's claim is paid ahead of the ordinary creditors up to half of its amount, unless it is one of those that the law ranks last.
  • Documentation. In voluntary proceedings, the debtor provides it with its petition. In creditor-initiated proceedings, the judge requires the debtor to submit it within ten days of being notified of the insolvency order.

What does not change

Apart from those differences, the procedure is the same. In both cases the judge appoints an insolvency practitioner, the creditors lodge their claims within a month of the insolvency order being published in Spain's Official State Gazette (“Boletín Oficial del Estado”) and the proceedings are generally resolved by a composition with the creditors (“convenio”) or by the liquidation of the assets. Insolvency proceedings without sufficient assets (“concurso sin masa”), those of a debtor who does not even have the assets to pay the costs of the procedure, follow their own rules and are a separate matter.

In both, the culpability section (“sección de calificación”) is also opened, in which the judge examines whether the insolvency was caused or aggravated by wilful misconduct or gross negligence. Petitioning for your own insolvency proceedings does not avoid that review. What petitioning in time does avoid is the legal presumption that the insolvency is culpable because no petition was filed within the time limit, which is a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.