When is an insolvency classified as culpable?

Insolvency proceedings (“concurso de acreedores”) are classified as culpable when the insolvency has been caused or aggravated by wilful misconduct or gross negligence on the part of the debtor or, if the debtor is a company, of its directors, liquidators or general managers, including de facto ones and those who held those posts in the previous two years. The law also lists certain cases in which the insolvency is always culpable, such as concealing assets or keeping seriously irregular accounts. In others it is presumed culpable unless the contrary is proved, such as when insolvency proceedings were not sought in time or the annual accounts were not filed. If none of those situations applies, the insolvency is fortuitous. The judge decides in a separate part of the proceedings, the culpability section (“sección de calificación”).

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

The general rule

A company failing or being unable to pay its debts does not make its insolvency culpable. The law requires two things. The first is wilful misconduct, that is, intentional conduct, or gross negligence, which is serious carelessness. The second is that this conduct caused the insolvency or made it worse.

The conduct examined is that of the debtor and its legal representatives. If the debtor is a company, that of its directors and liquidators, both those formally appointed and those who act as such without being so, who are known as de facto directors. Also that of its general managers and of anyone who held any of those posts in the two years before the insolvency order, so that resigning shortly beforehand does not avoid the classification. In addition, anyone who, through wilful misconduct or gross negligence, cooperated with them in the acts that make the insolvency culpable may be declared an accessory.

A director's liability for not having dissolved the company is another matter.

The cases listed by the law

The law lists situations in which the insolvency is culpable in any event, without any need to prove that they caused or aggravated the insolvency:

  • Concealing assets to the detriment of the creditors or any act that delays, hinders or prevents the effectiveness of an attachment in enforcement proceedings already under way or foreseeable.
  • The fraudulent removal of assets or rights from the debtor's property in the two years before the insolvency order.
  • Any act prior to the insolvency order aimed at simulating a fictitious financial position.
  • A serious inaccuracy in the documents submitted with the petition or during the proceedings, or the submission of false documents.
  • Substantial failure to comply with the duty to keep accounts, keeping a double set of accounts or an accounting irregularity that is relevant to understanding the asset or financial position.
  • The opening of the liquidation by the judge's own decision because the debtor failed to comply with the composition with creditors (“convenio”) for a reason attributable to it.

In other situations, the law presumes that the insolvency is culpable, unless the contrary is proved, when the debtor or its legal representatives, directors or liquidators:

  • Did not petition for insolvency proceedings within the statutory time limit, which is two months from when the insolvency was or should have been known.
  • Did not cooperate with the judge and the insolvency practitioner or did not give them the information necessary or useful for the proceedings.
  • Did not draw up the annual accounts, did not have them audited when required to do so or did not file them at the Companies Registry (“Registro Mercantil”), in any of the last three financial years.

Since these presumptions can be rebutted, having petitioned late does not automatically make the insolvency culpable, although it obliges whoever is affected to prove that the insolvency does not deserve that classification. Poor bookkeeping is different. If the failure is substantial or the irregularity is relevant, the insolvency is culpable, with nothing more required. A minor defect is not enough on its own.

Who asks for it and who decides

It is dealt with in the culpability section, which the judge opens at the end of the common stage (“fase común”), the first stage of the proceedings. The insolvency practitioner submits a reasoned report with a proposal, after receiving any submissions that the creditors and the other parties appearing in the proceedings wish to make. The creditors who made submissions can also present their own report if they represent at least 5 % of the debts or hold claims of more than one million euros. If any of those reports asks for the insolvency to be classified as culpable, the judge decides in a judgment. If not, the judge closes the file. The consequences of a culpable insolvency are another matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.