Is it legal to close a company with debts and open another?

Opening another company is legal, but a company with debts cannot simply be closed down. To extinguish it, its creditors must be paid first and, if it cannot pay them, what the law requires is to apply for insolvency proceedings, the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”, or, if it is a micro-enterprise, for the special procedure provided for micro-enterprises, within the legal time limit. What is not legal is to empty the old company so as not to pay its creditors and carry on the same business in a new one, to which the assets, contracts or customers are transferred without a real price. In that case the courts can make the new company and those behind it answer for the debts, the directors may have to pay out of their own assets and the conduct may even amount to a crime.

José Manuel Alburquerque

Alburquerque Abogados

Closing a company that has debts

Having debts does not prevent a company from being dissolved, but it affects how it is closed. In the liquidation, the liquidators must pay all the creditors before distributing anything to the shareholders. To execute the deed of extinction they must declare that the creditors have been paid or that what is owed to them has been lodged.

If the company's assets are not enough to pay everyone, the route is not an ordinary liquidation. A company that cannot regularly meet its obligations must apply for insolvency proceedings, the Spanish “concurso de acreedores”, or, if it is a micro-enterprise, for the special procedure provided for micro-enterprises, within two months of the date on which it knew, or should have known, that it was insolvent. The insolvency proceedings arrange payment of the creditors out of whatever assets there are and allow the company to be closed in an orderly way. Their detail is a separate matter.

What should not be done is to abandon the company with its debts, without dissolving it or applying for insolvency proceedings. This de facto closure does not extinguish the debts and exposes the directors to answering for them with their own assets.

Opening another company

Someone who has closed a business can start another with a new company, even in the same sector. Each company has its own assets and, in principle, the new one is not liable for the debts of the old one.

The problem arises when the new company is, in reality, the same business under another name. The courts then apply the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil, which allows the separation between companies to be disregarded when it is used to harm creditors. The result may be that the new company or its shareholders have to pay the debts of the old one. It is an exceptional remedy that requires the abuse to be proved. Signs such as these are usually taken into account:

  • That the two companies have the same shareholders or directors, or relatives of theirs.
  • That the new one carries on the same activity, at the same premises and with the same employees and customers.
  • That the old company's assets, stock or contracts have passed to the new one without a real price.
  • That the new one was set up when the old one could no longer pay its debts.

Other consequences

Besides piercing the corporate veil, creditors have other routes:

  • Claim against the directors of the old company. They are liable for debts arising after a legal ground for dissolution arose if they did not promptly bring about the dissolution or apply for insolvency proceedings. They are also liable for damage they cause directly to creditors.
  • Ask the judge to set aside sales or transfers of assets made so that the creditors could not collect.
  • Take the criminal route, because concealing assets or getting rid of them in order not to pay creditors may be a crime.

If the old company ends up in insolvency proceedings and these are classified as culpable, the directors may be ordered to cover all or part of what remains unpaid. They may also be disqualified from managing other people's property for a period of two to fifteen years, which prevents them from running another company. The tax authorities, Social Security and the employees have their own rules for claiming against whoever continues the business, which are a separate matter.

This answer is provided for educational purposes and offers initial guidance on the question raised. Every matter has its own circumstances and nuances that require individual assessment. For that reason, before taking decisions with significant consequences, it is advisable to consult a professional and not to rely solely on this information. Personalised advice makes it possible to apply these explanations to the specific case and to assess the options available with greater certainty.